Perceptions and predictors of organizational justice among healthcare professionals in academic hospitals in South-Eastern Nigeria

Abstract

Background: Research on organizational justice in hospitals in African countries are limited despite being important for workforce performance and hospital operational efficiency. This paper investigated perceptions and predictors of organizational justice among health professionals in academic hospitals in South-east Nigeria. Methods:The study was conducted in two teaching hospitals in Enugu State, South-east Nigeria using mixedmethods design. Randomly sampled 360 health professionals (doctors = 105, nurses = 200 and allied health professionals, AHPs = 55) completed an organizational justice scale. Additionally, semi-structured, in-depth interview with purposively selected 18 health professionals were conducted. Univariate and bivariate statistics and multivariable linear regression were used to analyze quantitative data. Statistical significance was set at alpha 0.05 level. Qualitative data were analyzed thematically using NVivo 11 software.Results: The findings revealed moderate to high perception of different dimensions of organizational justice. Doctors showed the highest perception, whereas AHPs had the least perception. Among doctors, age and education predicted distributive justice (adjusted R 2 = 22%); hospital ownership and education predicted procedural justice (adjusted R 2 = 17%); and hospital ownership predicted interactional justice (adjusted R 2 = 42%). Among nurses, age, gender and marital status predicted distributive justice (adjusted R 2 = 41%); hospital ownership, age and gender predicted procedural justice (adjusted R 2 = 28%); and hospital ownership, age, marital status and tenure predicted interactional justice (R 2 = 35%). Among AHPs, marital status predicted distributive justice (adjusted R 2 = 5%), while hospital ownership and tenure predicted interactional justice (adjusted R 2 = 15%). Qualitative findings indicate that nurses and AHPs perceive as unfair, differences in pay, access to hospital resources, training, work schedule, participation in decision-making and enforcement of policies between doctors and other health professionals due to medical dominance. Overall, supervisors have a culture of limited information sharing with, and disrespectful treatment of, their junior colleagues.(Continued on next page)

The Factors That Affect Turnover Intention According to Clinical Experience: A Focus on Organizational Justice and Nursing Core Competency

“…Even though nurses are one of the categories of healthcare professionals who provide actual medical services to patients, they tend to receive a relatively low wage compared to other healthcare professionals [ 3 ]. This correlates to the findings of previous studies that confirmed that the perceived organizational justice of nurses tended to be lower compared to that of other healthcare professionals, particularly doctors and pharmacists [ 34 ]. These findings suggest that nurses view their own compensation to be low given their working hours and the intensity of the work.…”

Nurses' perceptions of quality of work life in private hospitals in Enugu, Nigeria: A qualitative study

“…Even though a conducive working environment improves quality of nursing work life, the findings of this study highlighted several gaps in the work context which undermine the QWL and motivation of nurses. Nurses were blamed for most gaps in patient care, which is consistent with the blame culture found in prior studies [30] , [40] . Also, nurses lacked voice in the decision-making in private hospitals, as was found in other studies [6] , [20] , [32] .…”

Organizational justice and workplace spirituality: Their relation to organizational silence behavior among nurses

“…The results of the study revealed the statistically significant correlations among age, years of experience and gender variables with total organizational justice. This is result supported by Ghasi et al, [66] revealed the statistically significant relationship for the age variable with organizational justice, whereas increasing age predicted a high perception of justice among nurses. While according to Aldhafri and Alsaidi, [67] no found statistical differences were found in organizational justice with years of experience among teachers.…”