Perceived relevance of university physics problems by pre-service physics teachers: personal constructs

Abstract

Pre-service physics teachers often do not recognise the relevance for their future career in their university content knowledge courses. A lower perceived relevance can, however, have a negative effect on their motivation and on their academic success. Several intervention studies have been undertaken with the goal to increase this perceived relevance. A previous study shows that conceptual physics problems used in university physics courses are perceived by pre-service physics teachers as more relevant for their future career than regular, quantitative problems. It is however not clear, what the students' meaning of the construct 'relevance' is: what makes a problem more relevant to them than another problem? To answer this question, N = 7 pre-service teachers were interviewed using the repertory grid technique, based on the personal construct theory. Nine physics problems were discussed with regards to their perceived relevance and with regards to problem properties that distinguish these problems from each other. We are able to identify six problem properties that have a positive influence on the perceived relevance. Physics problems that are based on these properties should therefore potentially have a higher perceived relevance, which can have a positive effect on the motivation of the pre-service teachers who solve these problems. ARTICLE HISTORY

School-Related Content Knowledge in Organic Chemistry—How Does the Students’ Rating of Their Perceived Relevance of Tasks Differ between Bachelor and Master Studies?

“…If they perceive the tasks as relevant, this should promote learning. 14,15 The category "school-related content knowledge" in organic chemistry was examined in a Delphi study. Experts rated tasks related to the use of school knowledge, schoolrelated content knowledge, and university knowledge.…”

“…Bachelor's preservice physics and chemistry teachers rated tasks according to the SRCK concept as more relevant for their future profession than traditional tasks. 15,18 Unknown is how master's preservice teachers rate the relevance of such tasks and whether their opinion differs from that of the bachelor's preservice teachers. Therefore, in this study the following research questions are investigated and answered:…”

“…For science subjects, SRCK-specific tasks have been designed for chemistry and physics. The tasks developed for preservice physics teachers were evaluated by a questionnaire with regard to their perceived relevance for their future profession. , In general, tasks based on the SRCK-construct were recognized as more relevant than conventional physics problems by the preservice teachers.…”

Swimming against the Tide: Five Assumptions about Physics Teacher Education Sustained by the Culture of Physics Departments

“…It is common to teach trainee physics teachers together with future physicists and engineers (Massolt & Borowski, 2020;Vollmer, 2003). This way of organizing physics teacher education, where trainee physics teachers learn either the same or a subset of the same physics content that other physics students do, can be thought of as a practical implementation of the content assumption.…”

Perceived irrelevance and achievement goals: Two mindset variables within attitudinal experiences of life science majors in introductory physics

“…More recent efforts include a focus on perceived relevance within well-known attitudinal surveys in physics [25] or in terms of pre-service physics teachers' issues with their own perceived relevance of physics to their teaching careers. [26] In particular, it is a concern that life science majors, e.g. pre-medical students, may see a decline in perceived relevance over the course of a semester, as explicitly detailed by individual items on an attitudinal survey for physics.…”