Biorecognition is central to various biological processes and finds numerous applications in virtually all areas of chemistry, biology and medicine. Artificial antibodies, produced by imprinting synthetic polymers, are designed to mimic the biological recognition capability of natural antibodies, while exhibiting superior thermal, chemical and environmental stability compared to their natural counterparts. The binding affinity of the artificial antibodies to their antigens characterizes the biorecognition ability of these synthetic nanoconstructs and their ability to replace natural recognition elements. However, a quantitative study of binding affinity of artificial antibody to antigen, especially at the molecular level, is still lacking. Here, using atomic force microscopy-based force spectroscopy, we show that the binding affinity of an artificial antibody to an antigen (hemoglobin) is weaker than that of natural antibody. The fine difference in the molecular interactions manifests into a significant difference in the bioanalytical parameters of biosensors based on these recognition elements.