Peer Review #1 of "Greenhouse gas emissions from riparian zone cropland in a tributary bay of the Three Gorges Reservoir, China (v0.1)"

Abstract

Background. A huge reservoir was formed by the Three Gorges Dam in China, which also formed a riparian zone along the bank of the reservoir. In the period of low water-level, the riparian zone in tributary bays of the Three Gorges Reservoir (TGR) was always unordered cultivated, owing to its gentle slope and high soil fertility. This land-use practice creates high potential of generating greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions with periodic water level fluctuation. Methods. To evaluate potential GHG emissions from the soil-air interface, the static opaque chamber method was adopted to evaluate the effect of elevations (180 m, 175 m, 170m and 165 m) and land use types (dry lands, paddy fields and grass fields) from April to September in 2015 and 2016. Results. The results showed that carbon dioxide (CO 2) was the main contributor of GHG emission in riparian zone most likely because of high organic carbon from residues. Furthermore, high soil water content in paddy fields resulted in significantly higher methane (CH 4) flux than that in dry lands and grass fields. Compared to grass fields, anthropogenic activities in croplands were attributed with a decrease of soil total carbon and GHG emissions. However, i nundation duration of different elevations was found to have no significant effect on CH 4 and CO 2 emissions in the riparian zone, and the mean nitrous oxide (N 2 O) flux from dry lands at an elevation of 165m was significantly higher than that of other elevations likely because of tillage and manure application. The high N 2 O fluxes produced from tillage and fertilizer suggested that, in order to potentially mitigate GHG emissions from the riparian zone, more attention must be paid to the farming practices in dry lands at low elevations (below 165m) in the riparian zone. Understanding factors that contribute to GHG emissions will help guide ecological restoration of riparian zones in the TGR.