Peer Effects and Risk Sharing in Experimental Asset Markets

Abstract

Previous research has documented strong peer effects in risk taking, but little is known about how such social influences affect market outcomes. The consequences of social interactions are hard to isolate in financial data, and theoretically it is not clear whether peer effects should increase or decrease risk sharing. We design an experimental asset market with multiple risky assets and study how exogenous variation in real-time information about the portfolios of peer group members affects aggregate and individual risk taking. We find that peer information ameliorates under-diversification that occurs in a market without such information. One reason is that peer information increases risk aversion and induces a concern for relative income position that may reduce or amplify risk taking, depending on whether the context highlights the most or least successful trader. Thus, contrary to conventional wisdom, we show that social interactions may help to reduce earnings volatility in financial markets, and we discuss implications for institutional design. JEL-codes: D53, D83, G11.

Effects of Transparency: Analyzing Social Biases on Trader Performance in Social Trading

“…In order to improve the selection of experts, researchers proposed an algorithmic system that helps to identify and visualize expert traders based on their performance, risk, and consistency history (Lee and Ma, 2015). Furthermore, platform enabled social cues on individual (i.e., detailed decision information from peers) and network levels (i.e., aggregated decisions from the crowd) have been found to improve the risk management of otherwise risk averse investors (Zhao et al, 2015) by reducing under-diversification (Baghestanian et al, 2015). This effect, however, partially depends on the way in which the related peer information is framed.…”

“…This effect, however, partially depends on the way in which the related peer information is framed. Prominently displaying the highest earning trader can actually increase the risk affinity of the other users (Baghestanian et al, 2015). This is particularly relevant, since especially traders with a good past performance publicly present their strategies (Amman and Schaub, 2016), which might move people to underestimate risks.…”

The Influence of Upward Social Comparison on Retail Trading Behavior

“…Upward performance comparison (Schoenberg & Haruvy, 2012) and larger wealth inequality among market players (Deck, Hao, Xu & Yeager, 2021) lead to higher market prices and bubble metrics. Conversely, Baghestanian, Gortner and van der Weele (2015) found that exposing participants to the worst player's performance leads to less risky portfolio allocations.…”

How relative performance information affects employee behavior: a systematic review of empirical research

“…Baghestanian et al (2014) examined the moderating effect of characteristic variables . In their study, participants were aware of the portfolio choices of others.…”

“…Additionally, prices remain greater than the fundamental value for a longer period. Baghestanian et al (2014) examined the moderating effect of characteristic variables. In their study, participants were aware of the portfolio choices of others.…”