Payroll-exempt labor incomes increase inequality at the top

Abstract

In recent decades, inequality of household income has increased globally. A common trend is increased income inequality at the top of the distribution. The sources of this trend are a matter of debate. Increased demand for analytical and managerial skills is said to have strongly increased labor incomes at the top. Other scholars have indicated that structural conditions, such as financialization or favorable taxation, have benefited top-earning households. Here, we contribute to the latter line of reasoning. We show that payroll taxation reinforces income inequality at the top. Such taxation has large fiscal volume and redistributive power. However, our knowledge about the distributional consequences of payroll taxation as a tax scheme is remarkably thin. We claim that payroll taxes are central to understanding income inequality. Many countries, such as Germany and the US, restrict payroll taxes to a maximum amount, resulting in significant payroll tax-exempted incomes for high-earning households. Strongly growing top-labor incomes thus lead to increased payroll tax-exempted incomes for households at the upper parts of the distribution and, consequently, to higher income dispersion. We use Germany (1992–2017), a highly redistributive country, as a case study. Our empirical results suggest that: a) households increasingly profit from payroll-exempted labor incomes across the upper quarter; b) this benefit has increased over time; and c) increased amounts of payroll tax-exempted labor income explain up to 60% of income dispersion at the top of the distribution. We discuss the generalizability of our case study for other countries.

Quantile regression estimands and models: revisiting the motherhood wage penalty debate

“…Besides the parenthood wage penalty example discussed above, other examples of such research questions are whether the benefit of payroll taxation rules across the income distribution (Haupt & Nollmann, 2021), wage returns to education (Balestra & Backes-Gellner, 2017;Borgen, 2015), and socioeconomic achievement gradients (Grätz & Wiborg, 2020).…”

Who Profits from Occupational Licensing?

“…I explain the construction of this variable in detail in Part A of the online supplement. For Germany, I rely on the licensing data of Haupt, Witte, and Nollmann (2018).…”