Paying for Hemodialysis in Kerala, India: A Description of Household Financial Hardship in the Context of Medical Subsidy

Abstract

Introduction: Many low-and middle-income countries are implementing strategies to increase dialysis availability as growing numbers of people reach end-stage renal disease. Despite efforts to subsidize care, the economic sustainability of chronic dialysis in these settings remains uncertain. We evaluated the association of medical subsidy with household financial hardship related to hemodialysis in Kerala, India, a state with high penetrance of procedure-based subsidies for patients on dialysis. Methods: Patients on maintenance hemodialysis at 15 facilities in Kerala were administered a questionnaire that ascertained demographics, dialysis details, and household finances. We estimated direct and indirect costs of hemodialysis, and described the use of medical subsidy. We evaluated whether presence of subsidy (private, charity, or government-sponsored) was associated with lower catastrophic health expenditure (defined as $40% of nonsubsistence expenditure spent on dialysis) or distress financing. Results: Of the 835 patients surveyed, 759 (91%) reported their households experienced catastrophic health expenditure, and 644 (77%) engaged in distress financing. Median dialysis-related expenditure was 80% (25th-75th percentile: 60%-90%) of household nonsubsistence expenditure. Government subsidies were used by 238 (29%) of households, 139 (58%) of which were in the lowest income category. Catastrophic health expenditure was present in 215 (90%) of households receiving government subsidy and 332 (93%) without subsidy. Conclusions: Provision of medical subsidy in Kerala, India was not associated with lower rates of household financial hardship related to long-term hemodialysis therapy. Transparent counseling on impending costs and innovative strategies to mitigate household financial distress are necessary for persons with end-stage renal disease in resource-limited settings.

Causes, comorbidities and current status of chronic kidney disease: A community perspective from North Kerala

“…Probably they were more aware and better users of available services. [24] We understand that even among them the long term management of kidney disease will be difficult. In the background of very high prevalence of diabetes and hypertension we need clinical research to find out a screening test for early detection at primary levels and suggest life style modifications and provision of specific anti hypertensives.…”

Barriers to home dialysis: Unraveling the tapestry of policy

“…For many ESKD patients, particularly elderly patients in the COVID era, assisted PD may be more optimal than in-center HD, potentially reducing exposure risk for infection in transit or within the clinic itself. HD treatment is financially unattainable in many countries and recognized as universally financially distressing in a recent study in India 26. A study from New Zealand interviewed 52 patients with advanced CKD and their caregivers, confirmed that economic concerns are often present, strong, and underreported 27.…”

The Importance of Considering Total Patient Economics for Hemodialysis

“…In this issue of Kidney International Reports , Bradshaw et al. 3 address whether economic subsidies for patients with end-stage renal disease on dialysis in Kerala, India, impact catastrophic health expenses or distress financing. This question is especially relevant given that many countries have chosen to cover dialysis as a benefit under the premise that doing so will not only improve the lives of patients but also be more efficient for the health care system as a whole by reducing the number of emergency and hospitalization expenses.…”