Patterns of Pass‐through of Commodity Price Shocks to Retail Prices

Abstract

Commodity prices have been rising at unprecedented rates over the last two years. The primary objective of this paper is to assess if and how firms pass through upstream cost increases to final good prices. First, we investigate what happens to the shelf prices (the regular prices) of goods that contain significant amounts of a commodity whose price has changed. The objective is to document patterns of price rigidity depending on the share of the commodity in the final good that is sold to consumers. For example, given an abnormal commodity price change in wheat, what happens to the shelf regular price of bread, wheat cereals, and other goods that contain wheat? Commodity pass-through patterns for ready to eat cereal (smallest share of commodity in final product) and fresh chicken (largest share of commodity in final good) are investigated. Second, we also assess what happens to the net prices consumers pay (that is the regular price net of discounts offered). One possible way to pass through a cost increase is to reduce the frequency of promotional discounts, or offer smaller discounts to consumers. Upstream commodity input prices used in our investigation are wheat and corn futures prices, to account for upstream inputs, and flour and chicken feed producer price sub indices for downstream cost shocks.We combine several datasets for this empirical analysis: commodity prices, commodity price indices, and scanner data on prices for a variety of goods, over a four year time period and across several stores in California, belonging to a large retail chain. We construct quantity weighted price indices within two product categories sold in the supermarket, where prices are weighted by pre-determined quantity weights to obtain shelf price indices and net price indices. For each of the commodities, regressions will be run using store-level product (UPC) weekly data. The reduced form regressions consist of projecting the shelf price index, as well as the net price index, on commodity prices, other explanatory variables and on region and time dummies. The point estimates measure the effect of residual changes in commodity prices, net of seasonal and regional effects, on the prices consumers face when making purchase decisions. We also construct a variable that measures the frequency of price discounts and relate that variable to the same explanatory variables. We estimate pass through behavior using the above three different measures of retail price activity controlling for cost proxies, store-level fixed-effects and regional time trends using panel data estimation techniques. Results suggest that an important part of retail price variation comes from promotional activities, and the usual shelf price index would underestimate the true pass through coefficient. To deal with omitted variables and price stickiness we included a lagged dependent variable, using the Arellano-Bond dynamic panel estimator. For Chicken the results show that using standard information on regular shelf price leads to an underestimation of ...

Forty Years of Price Transmission Research in the Food Industry: Insights, Challenges and Prospects

“…Two other important features are worth noting: the rise of private (or own) label products, on which British food consumers now spend more than branded products; and the importance of price promotions, 40% of food being purchased when 'on sale' in the UK (Wisson, 2012). Both features are common to many countries, reflecting the changing nature of contracting within the food chain and have potentially important impacts on price transmission itself (Berck et al, 2009). For example, using a large scanner dataset of milk and butter prices in Germany, Loy et al (2015) find that private label products adjust faster (and more asymmetrically) to commodity shocks than national brands.…”

Do oil price increases cause higher food prices?

“…While these food price increases pale in comparison to those reported in some developing countries, as documented in Ivanic, Martin and Zaman (2012), this evidence spurred new research on the pass-through from energy and agricultural commodity prices to the retail price of food in the United States (see, e.g., Leibtag 2009;Berck, Leibtag, Solis and Villas-Boas 2009;Roeger and Leibtag 2011).…”

Global crude oil market shocks and global commodity prices

“…Higher crude oil prices will inevitably lead to higher fuel prices which are then passed on to businesses and consumers. Leibtag (2009) and Berck et al (2009) discuss the link between oil prices and commodity prices, and find some evidence of pass through from higher commodity prices to retail food prices. They, however, do not provide a comprehensive analysis of the impact of oil price shocks on commodity prices.…”