Patients’ Expectations Regarding Medical Treatment: A Critical Review of Concepts and Their Assessment

Abstract

Patients’ expectations in the context of medical treatment represent a growing area of research, with accumulating evidence suggesting their influence on health outcomes across a variety of medical conditions. However, the aggregation of evidence is complicated due to an inconsistent and disintegrated application of expectation constructs and the heterogeneity of assessment strategies. Therefore, based on current expectation concepts, this critical review provides an integrated model of patients’ expectations in medical treatment. Moreover, we review existing assessment tools in the context of the integrative model of expectations and provide recommendations for improving future assessment. The integrative model includes expectations regarding treatment and patients’ treatment-related behavior. Treatment and behavior outcome expectations can relate to aspects regarding benefits and side effects and can refer to internal (e.g., symptoms) and external outcomes (e.g., reactions of others). Furthermore, timeline, structural and process expectations are important aspects with respect to medical treatment. Additionally, generalized expectations such as generalized self-efficacy or optimism have to be considered. Several instruments assessing different aspects of expectations in medical treatment can be found in the literature. However, many were developed without conceptual standardization and psychometric evaluation. Moreover, they merely assess single aspects of expectations, thus impeding the integration of evidence regarding the differential aspects of expectations. As many instruments assess treatment-specific expectations, they are not comparable between different conditions. To generate a more comprehensive understanding of expectation effects in medical treatments, we recommend that future research should apply standardized, psychometrically evaluated measures, assessing multidimensional aspects of patients’ expectations that are applicable across various medical treatments. In the future, more research is needed on the interrelation of different expectation concepts as well as on factors influencing patients’ expectations of illness and treatment. Considering the importance of patients’ expectations for health outcomes across many medical conditions, an integrated understanding and assessment of such expectations might facilitate interventions aiming to optimize patients’ expectations in order to improve health outcomes.

Breast‐specific factors determine cosmetic outcome and patient satisfaction after breast‐conserving therapy: Results from the randomized COBALT study

“…It is well known that many breast cancer patients feel insufficiently informed about the impact of treatment modalities on their quality of life . Moreover, accumulating evidence suggests that expectations substantially influence treatment outcome . Optimizing the management of patient expectations regarding the secondary outcomes of breast conserving therapy could thereby contribute to improved overall satisfaction.…”

Optimizing preoperative expectations leads to a shorter length of hospital stay in CABG patients: Further results of the randomized controlled PSY-HEART trial

“…Second, our EXPECT intervention only focused on optimizing specific expectations such as treatment and recovery expectations and though there is a vast amount of literature on the associations between preoperative expectations and postoperative recovery, there has been no clear evidence yet which exact expectations specifically influence length of stay in CABG patients. The heterogeneity of concepts of expectations used in research is a well-known problem (56,57) which we addressed in a recent review (7). However, this is, to our knowledge, the first randomized controlled trial investigating the influence of an intervention specifically developed to optimize preoperative expectations in CABG patients and now further research is needed on precisely which expectations influence which outcomes.…”

“…Besides surgical procedures and medical interventions, psychological factors have a substantial predictive influence on health outcomes in heart disease (3)(4)(5). As shown in our recent reviews, expectations have been shown to be very prominent in recent research (6,7).…”

Patientenerwartungen optimieren: Beschreibung einer präoperativen Kurzintervention am Beispiel von Patienten vor einer Bypass-Operation

“…Trotz einer wachsenden Zahl an Studien, die die Wichtigkeit von Erwartungen im Zusammenhang mit verschiedenen medizinischen Problemen untersucht haben, ist es schwierig, die einzelnen Ergebnisse zusammenzufassen, da die Konzeptualisierung von Erwartungen und deren Erfassung sehr heterogen sind . Einen Ansatz für eine Integration bisheriger Forschungsergebnisse bietet das Integrative Erwartungsmodell von Laferton et al [2017], an dem sich dieser Artikel im Hinblick auf die Bezeichnung der Erwartungskonstrukte bereits orientiert.…”