Patients either contacting a general practice cooperative or accident and emergency department out of hours: a comparison

Abstract

Introduction: Lack of collaboration between general practice (GP) cooperatives and accident and emergency (A&E) departments and many self referrals may lead to inefficient out-of-hours care. Methods: We retrospectively analysed the records of all patients contacting the GP cooperative and all patients self referring to the A&E department out of hours in a region in the Netherlands. Results: 258 patients contacted the GP cooperative and 43 self referred to the A&E department per 1000 patients per year. A wide range of problems were seen in the GP cooperative, mainly related to infections (26.2%). The A&E department had a smaller range of problems, mainly related to trauma (66.1%).Relatively few urgent problems were seen in the GP cooperative (4.6%) or for self referrals in the A&E department (6.1%). Women, children, the elderly, and rural patients chose the GP cooperative significantly more often, as did men and patients with less urgent complaints, infections, and heart and airway problems. Discussion: The contact frequency of self referrals to the A&E department is much lower than that at the GP cooperative. Care is complementary: the A&E department focuses on trauma while the GP cooperative deals with a wide range of problems. The self referrals concern mostly minor, non-urgent problems and can generally be treated by the general practitioner, by a nurse, or by advice over the telephone, particularly in the case of optimal collaboration in an integrated care facility of GP cooperatives and A&E departments with one access point to medical care for all patients.

Streamline triage and manage user expectations: lessons from a qualitative study of GP out-of-hours services

“…This mismatch between their expectations of the consultation and the actual outcome needs to be addressed, 29 again through awareness-raising, education, and training. There is evidence that this can be successfully achieved, 30 but the findings of this study suggest that some service users perceive individual advice that is contrary to such goals, and this must be addressed urgently.…”

Can increased primary care access reduce demand for emergency care? Evidence from England's 7-day GP opening

“…One study found that 50% of self-referrals attend for injuries and ask for X-rays that would usually not be provided by a general practice but will be provided by an A&E centre (Giesen et al 2006). Patients often indicate that recommendations by family or friends influenced their decision to visit the A&E (Giesen et al 2006;Penson et al 2011). Patients also appear to search online for healthcare information before attending A&E (Benger and Jones 2008).…”

Social Marketing and Public Health

“…Users present with a wide range of conditions -some of which, although serious, may not warrant a specialist service. Complaints from staff about attendees 'that could have seen by their own GP instead' are therefore longstanding (Giesen et al, 2006;Murphy, 1998a;, 1998b;Sempere-Selva et al, 2001). Within London, Southwark and Lambeth Primary Care Trusts (PCTs) have each experienced a rise in the use of A&E and associated costs in recent years.…”