Patients as Teachers, Medical Students as Filmmakers: The Video Slam, A Pilot Study

Abstract

In 2006-2007 and 2007-2008, the authors pilot-tested a filmmaking project, (medical students filmed patients) to assess the project's potential to teach about the challenges of living with serious chronic illness. Two years of second-year medical students (N = 32) from The University of Arizona, working in groups of two or three, were paired with patients and filmed multiple home visits during eight months. Students edited their films to 7 to 10 minutes and added transitions, titles, and music. A mixed audience of students and faculty viewed the resulting 12 films in a "Video Slam." Faculty also used the films in the formal curriculum to illustrate teaching points related to chronic illness. Student filmmakers, on average, made 4.4 visits, collected 5.6 hours of film, and edited for 26.6 hours. Students reported that the project affected what they planned to cover in clinic visits, increased their plans to involve patients in care, enhanced their appreciation for patient-centered care, improved their knowledge of community resources, improved their understanding of allied health professionals' roles, and taught them about patients' innovative adaptations. Overall, students rated the project highly for its impact on their education (mean = 4.52 of 5). Student and faculty viewers of the films (N = 74) found the films compelling (mean = 4.95 of 5) and informative (mean = 4.93 of 5). The authors encountered the ethical dilemmas of deciding who controls the patients' recorded stories and navigating between patient anonymity/confidentiality and allowing patients to use their stories to teach.

A guiding framework to maximise the power of the arts in medical education: a systematic review and metasynthesis

“…Our team has expertise in the medical humanities, library sciences, health services and educational research, and arts‐based education . We conducted a qualitative metasynthesis, defined by Sandelowski and Barroso as ‘a systematic approach to the collection and analysis of qualitative studies, a focus on the findings from those studies, and the use of qualitative methods to synthesise those findings’.…”

Transforming Undergraduate Student Perceptions of Dementia through Music and Filmmaking

“…This study expands on the existing literature by shifting the disciplinary foundation and campus location of these courses from the health sciences departments of gerontology, nursing, and speech and hearing therapy into arts and music departments. Furthermore, although studies have discussed filmmaking as a valuable methodology for teaching personhood in geriatric education, this study illustrates how filmmaking can be used as a productive educational tool in documenting and enhancing curricula involving other forms of arts‐based engagement.…”

“…Unlike the prior studies, this course was placed within the School of Arts and Sciences, rather than in the health sciences. As a result of the course placement within the undergraduate university system, the professor was able to engage a group of students who might not otherwise have thought to engage in a dementia workforce.…”

“…Studies involving arts and music have been conducted in nursing programs and medical schools . Most studies focus on using arts and music to change perceptions about dementia among health sciences professional trainees, but trainees comprise a small and already differentiated population. If we are to build a workforce, educators need to move upstream.…”

Training Health Care Professionals for 21st-Century Practice

“…Health System Organization of Health Care 57 Desguin 45 Lausen et al 63 LoFaso et al 46 Mullen et al 47 Nieman & Cheng 60 O'Connell et al 52 Schreier et al 48 Shapiro et al 49 Waddell & Davidson 44 (N = 10) Dent et al 53 Diederiks et al 54 Janson et al 64 Jerant et at 55 Lennon-Dearing et al 58 LoFaso et al 46 Nuovo et al 51 Plake 50 Stevens et al 65 Shapiro et al 49 (N = 10)…”