Patients' Advice to Physicians About Intervening in Family Conflict

Abstract

PURPOSE We wanted to understand patients' views about physician interventions with family violence and confl ict.METHODS Clinic staff surveyed 253 male and female family practice patients in 6 member offi ces of the South Texas Ambulatory Research Network (STARNet). The survey instrument addressed demographics, relationship quality, intimate partner violence, and physician interventions with family confl ict. Open-ended questions asked respondents to provide advice for "doctors who want to help patients with severe family problems." RESULTS Among women in relationships, 10% reported being physically hurt by a partner in the past year and 39% in their lifetimes. Among men in relationships, 7% reported physically hurting their partner in the past year and 16% in their lifetimes. Nearly all respondents, including 100% of victims and perpetrators of violence, believed physicians should ask about family confl ict (96%), and that physicians could be helpful (93%). Two thirds of the sample reported that their physician had never asked them about family confl ict. Investigators used qualitative analysis to summarize patients' advice to physicians. Responses clustered around 3 general themes: communication, assistance, and cautions or encouragement. Patients want physicians to ask about family confl ict, listen to their stories, and provide information and appropriate referrals. They raised some cautions and concerns, but also provided words of encouragement. CONCLUSIONMost patients are open to discussions about family confl ict with their physicians. The skills they recommend to physicians are well within the domain of family medicine training.

Effects of a Couple Communication Program on Marital Adjustment

“…10,48 -50 An understanding of the basic techniques of the behavioral sciences can help physicians be more alert to patients' marital problems and better allow them to make appropriate recommendations for more intensive therapy. 6,7,10,50 With the skills required to support troubled marriages, the family physician of the future may be able to make a significant contribution to the preservation of the nuclear family. 51 Efforts have been made to integrate the behavioral sciences with medical sciences in residency or postgraduate programs to meet patients' psychosocial needs.…”

Domestic violence: knowledge, attitudes, and clinical practice of selected UK primary healthcare clinicians

“…11,12 Women experiencing abuse have frequent contact with primary care clinicians, 13,14 and consider it appropriate to be asked about domestic violence by doctors and nurses. 15 They also identify healthcare professionals as potential sources of support if this is delivered in a non-judgemental and nondirective manner, and an appreciation of the complexity of domestic violence is shown. 16 Historically, however, the quality of care for women experiencing abuse has been poor worldwide.…”

Intimate partner violence: treating abuser and abused

“…Patients agree that physicians should ask about such violence and believe that they can be helpful in dealing with it (Burge et al, 2005). Indeed, compared with 5 years ago, family physicians are asking more frequently about intimate partner violence, resulting in improved patient mental health and acceptance of treatment (Glowa et al, 2003).…”