Patient Satisfaction with Transgender Health Services

Abstract

Measuring patient satisfaction (i.e., patients' subjective evaluation of health care services received) is increasingly important in assessing health care outcomes because of the current emphasis on greater partnership between providers (therapist, doctor, staff) and consumers (patients) in health care. In care of transgender persons, achieving good patient satisfaction is particularly challenging given the primary role mental health professionals play as arbiters of who has access to sex reassignment and when such candidates are ready. Dependence on a mental health professional in this "gate-keeping" role is perceived by some members of the transgender community as unnecessarily pathologizing. This study compared satisfaction ratings of 180 transgender and 837 other sexual health patients with psychotherapeutic, psychiatric, and sexual medicine services provided at a university-based sexual health clinic. Five consecutive surveys conducted during 1993-2002 showed high patient satisfaction. We found few significant differences between transgender and other sexual health patients, except that in 1995, transgender patients had higher satisfaction on their perceived ability to handle the problems that originally had led them to therapy. Survey results helped target areas in need of improvement (e.g., friendliness and courtesy of staff, handling of phone calls), and efforts by the providers to improve services resulted in significant increases in patient satisfaction. These findings put individual complaints in perspective and showed that despite the challenges inherent in providing transgender care good satisfaction can be achieved. We encourage providers to implement quality assurance and improvement procedures to give patients the opportunity to provide feedback and have a voice in shaping their own health care.

559 Gender reassignment surgery – a 13 year review of surgical outcomes

“…no functional complaints have been reported till now, although in some cases lost of depth has been reported. Attempts using intestinal interposition have shown no advantages compared to skin flaps, especially if complications are considered (29,30). For this reason we indicate up to two reconstructions with skin flaps before using ileal segments.…”

HIV Infection Risk Factors Among Male-to-Female Transgender Persons: A Review of the Literature

“…Once educated, HCPs are more likely to work closely with transgender women to assure that these women receive appropriate health care services (Dewey, 2008). A study by Bockting, Robinson, Benner, and Scheltema (2004) compared client satisfaction of transgender women and biological females in terms of mental health and sexual health services. Both groups reported a dislike and distrust of the role of the physician as the gatekeeper of care and services, and there were few differences in the level of client satisfaction between the two groups.…”

A Community-Based Program Evaluation of Community Competency Trainings

“…Many scholars who have studied transgender health care have recommended and emphasized the need for clinical and staff training to improve provider-patient relationships and increase use of care (Bockting, Robinson, Benner, & Scheltema, 2004;Kenagy, 2005;Lombardi, 2001). In one of the few studies conducted on transgender patient satisfaction with health care services, a significant correlation was reported between levels of satisfaction and patients' perception of the therapists' expertise in transgender health (Rachlin, 2002).…”