Patient burden during appointment-making telephone calls to GP practices

Abstract

Objective: This study addresses, for the first time, the effectiveness of receptionists handling incoming calls from patients to access General Practice services. Methods: It is a large-scale qualitative study of three services in the UK. Using conversation analysis, we identified the issue of 'patient burden', which we defined based on the trouble patients display pursuing service. We quantified instances of 'patient burden' using a coding scheme. Results: We demonstrate how 'patient burden' unfolds in two phases of the telephone calls: (i) following an initial rejection of a patient's request; and (ii) following a receptionist's initiation of call closing. Our quantitative analysis shows that the three GP services differ in the frequency of 'patient burden' and reveals a correlation between the proportion of 'patient burden' and independent national satisfaction scores for these surgeries. Conclusion: Unlike post-hoc surveys, our analysis of live calls identifies the communicative practices which may constitute patient (dis)satisfaction. Practice Implications: Through establishing what receptionists handle well or less well in encounters with patients, we propose ways of improving such encounters through training or other forms of intervention.

“Keeping it on your radar”—assessing the barriers and facilitators to a timely diagnosis of type 1 diabetes in childhood: A qualitative study from the early detection of type 1 diabetes in youth study

“…This concept recognizes that it is the patient that has to drive for a successful outcome during the appointment making process, rather than the receptionist proffering solutions. 29 These findings are consistent with our data which recognized the influence of the carer on successfully obtaining an appointment.…”

“…Research on the interactions between patients and receptionists is limited, but a study of three UK GP practices where 2780 phone calls of patients seeking appointments with a receptionist were analysed identified the concept of “patient burden”. This concept recognizes that it is the patient that has to drive for a successful outcome during the appointment making process, rather than the receptionist proffering solutions . These findings are consistent with our data which recognized the influence of the carer on successfully obtaining an appointment.…”

Taking data seriously: the value of actor-network theory in rethinking patient experience data

“…For example, whereas hospitals are formally hierarchical institutions with a wide range of fixed roles and responsibilities, the contingent interactions in which data get embedded may reveal alternative decision-making processes, and may bring to the fore the role of certain actors (such as health care assistants or receptionists) who are conventionally marginal, but who nevertheless often come to play an unexpectedly central role in ensuring the quality of care. 8,9 …”

Enquiry calls to GP surgeries in the United Kingdom: Expressions of incomplete service and dissatisfaction in closing sequences

“…Recent developments in conversation analysis suggest that we may be able to identify features of (dis)satisfaction endogenously within conversations (Woods et al, 2015;Sikveland et al, 2016), which is relevant for our second empirical Schegloff, 2007 for in-depth analysis).…”