Patient Adherence With At-Home Hand and Wrist Exercises: A Randomized Controlled Trial of Video Versus Handout Format

Abstract

Background: Patient adherence is important for maximizing patient outcomes. The purpose of this randomized controlled trial was to determine patient adherence and confidence in home therapy exercises of the hand and wrist at multiple time points when distributed by either paper handout or video. Methods: Patients were prospectively enrolled and randomized in orthopedic clinics to either the handout or video exercise group. Exclusion criteria included patients less than 18 years old. Questionnaires were electronically distributed each week for 4 weeks following enrollment. Questionnaires assessed the frequency of exercise performance, percentage of exercises utilized, and confidence in performing the exercises correctly. The handout and video groups were compared via 2-sample t tests for continuous data and χ2 tests for categorical data. Results: Of the 89 patients enrolled, 71 patients responded to the initial follow-up survey (80% of randomized patients), and 54 of these patients (76%) completed all surveys at each time point. The handout group (37 patients) and the video group (34 patients) had no differences in response rate or demographics. There were no differences in frequency, exercise utilization rate, or confidence in performing exercises between groups at week 1. However, the video group reported higher exercise utilization and confidence than the handout group at subsequent time points. Conclusions: Video-format distribution of home therapy exercises is superior to that of paper handout distribution for the distal upper extremity rehabilitation. Patients in the video group utilized more exercises and had higher confidence in completing them correctly following initiation of the exercise program.

Clinical Efficacy of Application-Linked Stretching Ball as Digital Therapeutics in Plantar Fasciitis

“…Nonetheless, we provided both groups with an informative brochure containing text and simple illustrations on the general principles of physiotherapy for the treatment of plantar fasciitis, such as rolling or Achilles tendon stretching. Previous studies have suggested that distributing home therapy exercises in a video-format is superior to paper handouts for at-home hand and wrist rehabilitation [38]. It was noted that patients in the video group utilized more exercises and had higher confidence in completing them correctly after starting the exercise program.…”

What’s New in Hand and Wrist Surgery

“…Several studies were published comparing written and video-based patient educational materials. Patients reported higher satisfaction, better comprehension, safer opioid use, and increased utilization of exercises with video materials compared with written handouts [63][64][65][66] .…”

Barriers and facilitators to engaging with a digital self‐management programme for painful distal upper limb musculoskeletal disorders: A qualitative exploratory study

“…Specific types of exercises such as grip‐strengthening exercises are often recommended for the improvement of DUL‐MSDs 22 . However, exercise rehabilitation requires completion over several weeks and there are difficulties in sustaining adherence to exercise programmes, 23 with a lack of evidence about intensity and dosage of exercise programmes 22 . Exercise may be optimised with guided self‐management support 24 …”