Paternalistic and transactional HRM: the nature and transformation of HRM in contemporary China

Abstract

Drawing on institutionalism and path dependency theory, this paper provides a conceptual framework to identify and explain the nature and transformation of Chinese human resource management (HRM). The framework is applied to case studies of three enterprises that are either state-owned or state-controlled. The paper groups HRM in contemporary China into three categories: Paternalistic; Transactional; and Differentiated with the last one involving a mix of paternalistic and transactional HRM policies and practices. The paper argues that, as China's economy has evolved from paternalistic socialism to market socialism in recent decades, Chinese HRM has responded, moving along the continuum from paternalistic to transactional HRM. The case studies reveal the impact on HRM practice of both the legacy of paternalistic socialism and three decades of marketization. The case study evidence clearly indicates that paternalistic HRM, common in state-owned enterprises in the pre-reform era, has evolved towards either transactional or diffe\rentiated HRM. Among the changes in HRM practice is a decline in the welfare benefits and employment security of workers, the former 'masters of society'.

Human Resource Practices and Firm Performance in China: The Moderating Roles of Regional Human Capital Quality and Firm Innovation Strategy

“…In particular, researchers pointed out that the primary purposes of training in Chinese firms is to arm employees with basic KSAs required by work tasks (Ng & Siu, 2004) and to enhance ideological and political consciousness through moral education (Zhu, Zhang, & Shen, 2012). As a result, employees are likely to obtain general KSAs that are transferrable among firms.…”

Contextualizing HRM in China: differences within the country

“…One could make a similar argument about the paucity of historical contributions (see e.g. Zhu, Zhang, & Shen, 2012 as an exception).…”

Reassessing the role of Chinese workers in problem solving: a study of transformational leadership, trust and security in ‘lean’ manufacturing

“…Chinese workers have been gradually losing the job security they once enjoyed due to changes in labour laws, human resource management practices and firms' competitive environments (Warner and Zhu 2002;Zhu, Zhang, and Shen 2012;Loi et al 2011). These changes in working environment should heighten the impact of workers' perceived security upon organizational performance and worker behaviour.…”