Participation of women in the health workforce in the fragile and conflict-affected countries: a scoping review

Abstract

Introduction and background The full participation of women as healthcare providers is recognized globally as critical to favorable outcomes at all levels, including the healthcare system, to achieving universal health coverage and sustainable development goals (SDGs) by 2030. However, systemic challenges, gender biases, and inequities exist for women in the global healthcare workforce. Fragile and conflict-affected states/countries (FCASs) experience additional pressures that require specific attention to overcome challenges and disparities for sustainable development. FCASs account for 42% of global deaths due to communicable, maternal, perinatal, and nutritional conditions, requiring an appropriate health workforce. Consequently, there is a need to understand the impact of gender on workforce participation, particularly women in FCASs. Methods This scoping review examined the extent and nature of existing literature, as well as identified factors affecting women's participation in the health workforce in FCASs. Following Arksey and O'Malley's scoping review methodology framework, a systematic search was conducted of published literature in five health sciences databases and grey literature. Two reviewers independently screened the title and abstract, followed by a full-text review for shortlisted sources against set criteria. Results Of 4284, 34 sources were reviewed for full text, including 18 primary studies, five review papers, and 11 grey literature sources. In most FCASs, women predominate in the health workforce, concentrated in nursing and midwifery professions; medicine, and the decision-making and leadership positions, however, are occupied by men. The review identified several constraints for women, related to professional hierarchies, gendered socio-cultural norms, and security conditions. Several sources highlight the post-conflict period as a window of opportunity to break down gender biases and stereotypes, while others highlight drawbacks, including influences by consultants, donors, and non-governmental organizations. Consultants and donors focus narrowly on programs and interventions solely serving women's reproductive health rather than taking a comprehensive approach to gender mainstreaming in planning human resources during the healthcare system’s restructuring. Conclusion The review identified multiple challenges and constraints facing efforts to create gender equity in the health workforce of FCASs. However, without equal participation of women in the health workforce, it will be difficult for FCASs to make progress towards achieving the SDG on gender equality.

Strengthening health systems and peacebuilding through women’s leadership: a qualitative study

“…Our findings are in accordance with the literature that highlights the barriers to or exclusion of women's leadership in both health systems and peacebuilding initiatives [24,27,37,[60][61][62]. These barriers include Fig.…”

“…Leadership in health in conflict can also be considered a long-term investment. A lack of investment in long-term strategies and interventions in conflict settings more broadly hinders the development of appropriate health systems strengthening agendas, as demonstrated in Syria and Afghanistan, where there has not been any sustained investment in the development of future women health systems leaders [34][35][36][37].…”

The Perception of Nursing Professionals Working in a Central Sterile Supplies Department regarding Health Conditions, Workload, Ergonomic Risks, and Functional Readaptation

“…Among the sociodemographic characteristics analyzed in this study, there was a clear predominance of female nursing professionals. Historically, the art of caring is linked to the figure of the woman, which is reflected in the increase in the workforce in health units, not only in Brazil but also in other countries [ 12 , 15 ]. By observing the profile of nursing professionals, it was possible to identify a clear predominance of nursing technicians, which suggests that these people have other professions that do not require university education.…”

The state of nursing and midwifery leadership, governance structures, and instruments in Africa

“…This study shows that nursing and midwifery structures are led by women. This can be attributed to the fact nursing and midwifery are female-led professions in Africa [12]. Nursing and midwifery leadership roles come with the expectation that one should be equipped with adequate skills to run designated tasks, including the development and implementation of governance instruments.…”