Parental happiness and social policy in Asia

Abstract

People in East and South Asia widely believe that having children brings fulfillment to an individual's life. However, over the past fifty years, modernisation in Asia has been accompanied by a remarkable drop in birth rates to a level even lower than most western countries. Prior research on western nations has shown that the time demands and financial stresses of parenthood, as well as current inflexible employment practices, contribute to the high cost of parenthood and discount the emotional rewards of having children. This study investigates the happiness of parents and childless individuals in East and South Asia, and whether social policies can improve parental happiness. We use individual-level data in 10 Asian countries from the World Values and the Asian Barometer Surveys, and find no country where parents report significantly greater happiness than non-parents after controlling for relevant sociodemographic differences. Multilevel models show that paid annual leave, paid maternity and parental leave, and flexible working schedules as well as a comprehensive policy index help alleviate the disparity in happiness between parents and non-parents across countries, in particular work flexibility, while family-friendly policies have no noticeable negative effects on non-parents' wellbeing.

Earning Too Little And Worrying Too Much: The Role Of Income And Financial Worries On Parents’ Well-Being In Hong Kong And Bangkok

“…It is widely believed that parenthood brings happiness and joy to individuals (Hansen, 2012 ). However, most empirical evidence from Asian (Chao & Glass, 2020 ) and Western societies (Hansen, 2012 ; Stanca, 2012 ) suggests that having children provides no additional happiness to parents relative to non-parents. One explanation for this paradox comes from the family economic stress model, which suggests that the increased financial worry that comes with having to raise a child dampens the joy associated with parenthood (Conger et al, 2010 ; Stanca, 2012 ).…”