Parent–child picture-book reading, mothers' mental state language and children's theory of mind

Abstract

This study focuses on parent–child book reading and its connection to the development of a theory of mind. First, parents were asked to report about frequency of parent–child storybook reading at home. Second, mothers were asked to read four picture-books to thirty-four children between 4;0 and 5;0. Both frequency of parent–child storybook reading at home, and mother's use of mental state terms in picture-books reading tasks were significantly associated with success on false belief tasks, after partialling out a number of potential mediators such as age of children, verbal IQ, paternal education, and words used by mothers in joint picture-book reading. Among the different mental state references (cognitive terms, desires, emotions and perceptions), it was found that the frequency and variety of cognitive terms, but also the frequency of emotional terms correlated positively with children's false belief performance. Relationships between mental state language and theory of mind are discussed.

Emotional state talk and emotion understanding: a training study with preschool children

“…Therefore, emotion language is not just a component of emotional competence; it is also a manifestation of 'theory of mind ' (ToM), the child's growing awareness of the existence of internal states in itself and in others (Harris, 1989 ;. Both cross-sectional (Dunn, Brown & Beardsale, 1991 ;Astington & Jenkins, 1999 ;de Villiers & de Villiers, 2000 ;Adriàn, Clemente, Villanueva & Rieffe, 2005;Astington & Baird, 2005) and training (Lohmann & Tomasello, 2003 ;Hale & Tager-Flusberg, 2003 ;Grazzani Gavazzi & Ornaghi, 2008) studies have shown that language plays a crucial role in fostering children's understanding of the mind (Milligan, Astington & Dack, 2007). Recent findings support the hypothesis of a bi-directional relationship between theory of mind and language (Slade & Ruffman, 2005) although the effect of language on theory of mind seems to be stronger than the other way round.…”

The Invisible Kryptonite Among Super Helpers the Healers of Humanity: Advocating for Super Helpers to Practice What They Preach to Clients?

“…For example, during unstructured play sessions mother's tendency to comment on emotions and desires (e.g., happy, sad, hate, love, hurt, sorry) that were appropriate to the situation predicted children's theory of mind [64]. Comparable results were found between a child's theory of mind and their parent's tendency to talk about mental states (e.g., intentions, beliefs) when reading with their child [65,66,61]. Similarly, parent-guided reminiscing about past events allowed children to construct relations between both the past and present, as well as the self and other, which is critical to the development of theory of mind [67].…”

Cognitive Literary Studies: Current Themes and New Directions

“…In children, use of terms for mental states (desires, emotions, etc.) as well as success in theory-of-mind tasks was studied by Adrian et al (2005). Children's use of terms for mental states and their abilities in theory of mind were found to be related both to the amount of reading mothers did with them and to the number of mental state terms that mothers used when they read picture books to their children.…”