Paradoxes of Intersectionality: Theorizing Inequality in the Dutch Police Force through Structure and Agency

Abstract

While gender and ethnic inequality have been extensively studied in the context of organizations, research into how the intersection of these and other identity categories (re)produces inequality in organizations is still scarce. In this article, we examine inequality from an intersectional perspective in the context of a diverse and multifaceted organization: the Dutch police force. Using data collected through direct observation and focus groups, we analyse how organizational inequality is (re)produced and called into question by drawing on intersecting gender, ethnic and organizational identities. The analysis on the findings through an intersectional lens sheds light onto two paradoxes. The first paradox points to the fact that, by deploying more positive identities to empower themselves, individuals can de facto contribute to reproducing inequalities along those same identity axes. The second suggests, on the contrary, that acknowledging female and ethnic minority officers’ specific valuable competences calls into question inequality along gender and ethnicity within the executive police force. In analysing our material, we approach individuals as agents reflecting and engaging with intersecting identities and the unequal power relations deriving from them. We show that, while they occasionally openly challenge inequality derived from one’s social identity, they often actually reproduce it in order to preserve their own individual power.

The Tipping Point: The Intersection of Race, Gender, and Sexual Orientation in Intercollegiate Sports

“…Additional studies show how downplaying a marginalized identity, or emphasizing a valued identity, may help minorities avoid some forms of prejudice or discrimination (Boogaard & Roggeband, 2010;Melton & Cunningham, 2012b, 2014a. For instance, Boogaard and Roggeband (2010) examined the intersection of multiple identities as well as the negotiation of identities within a Dutch Police force.…”

“…For instance, Boogaard and Roggeband (2010) examined the intersection of multiple identities as well as the negotiation of identities within a Dutch Police force. Their findings suggest that those who employed the identity that supports the institutional norms (e.g., women adapting more masculine behaviors and characteristics to fit in with a masculine culture) managed to enhance their professional opportunities but also perpetuated the same exclusive culture, which inhibit opportunities for less masculine individuals.…”

Exploring the experiences of women and migrant medical professionals in Swedish hospitals

“…Sociologist Joan Acker's (2006) concept of inequality regimes has contributed to a range of studies on how gender, class, ethnicity and sexuality shape the distribution of power and resources as well as identity formations (Healy et al, 2011;Boogard and Roggeband, 2010).…”

“Making up” workers in an inclusive organisation

“…First, they argue that agency and resistance among employees is largely unacknowledged in comparison to the power of managers (Zanoni and Janssens, 2007). Second, material aspects of work and organisation are often left out in discourse-oriented studies of diversity (Boogaard and Roggeband, 2009;Zanoni and Janssens, 2007) and third, scholars highlight the importance of attending to the intersectionality of multiple identities in work organisations (Ashcraft, 2009;Holvino, 2008). To investigate these issues, several scholars call for close and detailed empirical studies of inclusion and diversity in local organisational settings (Ashcraft et al, 2012;Holvino and Kamp, 2009;Zanoni and Janssens, 2004).…”