Paradigms in Industrial Relations: Original, Modern and Versions In‐between

Abstract

This article argues that the industrial relations (IR) field has had two distinct paradigms - an original paradigm centred on the employment relationship, and a modern paradigm centred on unions and labour-management relations. In practice, IR scholars in the decades after the Second World War frequently adopted the former as a broad principle but followed the latter in research and teaching. The narrower labour-management paradigm has created a significant survival challenge for the IR field, given the marked long-term decline in union density in most countries. I join with others in arguing that to survive and prosper in the years ahead, the field needs to return to an updated version of the original 'employment relationship' paradigm. To promote this end, I describe the major features of the original paradigm, including its core positive and normative principle. I also outline how this core principle provides the foundation for an integrative IR theory of the employment relationship, which the field greatly needs to move ahead. Copyright (c) Blackwell Publishing Ltd/London School of Economics 2008.

Corporate Social Responsibility, Organizational Justice and Positive Employee Attitudes: In the Context of Korean Employment Relations

“…Kaufman [91] has argued that since the 1960s employee-employer relations, especially in the US, have been seen as pluralistic, antagonistic, and conflicting. The antagonistic view of employee-management relations, though dominant in much research, is not the only view of employment relations.…”

The Debate on Globalization and International Revitalization of Labor. A Critical Review

“…The industrial working class, trade unions, and social democracy had a progressive era of laborism and decommodification, building occupational citizenship and safety rules. This era brought increased labor market regulation, in line with ILO's principle idea that "labour is not a commodity" (Kaufman 2004(Kaufman , 2008. The industrial citizenship includes rights and safety rules regarding seven areas: labor market conditions, employment, occupational safety, work environment, work competence, income, and collective representation (unions) (Standing 2011: 10).…”

The prospects for family business in research universities

“…is that of labor relations, a decline due in part to the weakening role of labor unions (Kaufman, 2008;Lansbury, 2009). We do not foresee family business facing this fate due to a diminishing presence of the actual phenomenon.…”