In this paper, we minimize and compare two different fine-tuning measures in four high-scale supersymmetric models that are embedded in the MSSM. In addition, we determine the impact of current and future dark matter direct detection and collider experiments on the fine-tuning. We then compare the low-scale electroweak measure with the high-scale Barbieri-Giudice measure, which generally do not agree. However, we find that they do reduce to the same value when the higgsino parameter drives the degree of finetuning. Depending on the high-scale model and fine-tuning definition, we find a minimal fine-tuning of 3 − 38 (corresponding to O(10 − 1)%) for the low-scale measure, and 63 − 571 (corresponding to O(1 − 0.1)%) for the high-scale measure. In addition, minimally finetuned spectra give rise to a dark matter relic density that is between 10 −3 < Ωh 2 < 1, when µ determines the minimum of the fine-tuning. We stress that it is too early to conclude on the fate of supersymmetry, based only on the fine-tuning paradigm.