“…Iron silicates such as minnesotaite, greenalite, and stilpnomelane have long been identified in BIFs, but the consensus view categorized these as secondary minerals or derived from volcanic input (Beukes & Gutzmer, 2008;Fischer & Knoll, 2009;Haugaard et al, 2016;Klein, 2005). However, primary magnetic remanences that should have been recorded in original hematite precipitates, if they stayed below 600°C, have never been found in the Australian Hamersley Group and South African Transvaal Supergroup BIFs (Abrajevitch et al, 2014;de Kock et al, 2009;Humbert et al, 2017;Li et al, 1993)-highly suggestive of hematite being emplaced secondarily. However, primary magnetic remanences that should have been recorded in original hematite precipitates, if they stayed below 600°C, have never been found in the Australian Hamersley Group and South African Transvaal Supergroup BIFs (Abrajevitch et al, 2014;de Kock et al, 2009;Humbert et al, 2017;Li et al, 1993)-highly suggestive of hematite being emplaced secondarily.…”