Oral Glucose before Venepuncture Relieves Neonates of Pain, but Stress Is Still Evidenced by Increase in Oxygen Consumption, Energy Expenditure, and Heart Rate

Abstract

Oral glucose was recommended as pain therapy during venepuncture in neonates. It is unclear whether this intervention reduces excess oxygen consumption (o(2)), energy loss, or cardiovascular destabilization associated with venepuncture, and whether <2 mL glucose solution is effective. We tested the hypothesis that oral glucose solution attenuates the increases in neonatal oxygen consumption, energy expenditure (EE), and heart rate associated with venepuncture for two different volumes of glucose solution (2 and 0.4 mL). In this prospective, randomized, controlled, double-blind trial, 58 neonates (gestational age, 31-42 wk; postnatal age, 1-7 d) were randomized to 2 mL glucose 30%, 0.4 mL glucose 30%, or 2 mL water by mouth before venepuncture. The videotaped behavioral pain reactions were scored with the Premature Infant Pain Profile. Cry duration, o(2), EE (indirect calorimetry), and heart rate were measured. The 2 mL glucose solution reduced pain score and crying after venepuncture compared with controls [median pain score, 5.5 (interquartile range, 4-9) versus 11 (7-12), p = 0.01; median duration of first cry, 0 s (0-43 s) versus 13 s (2-47 s), p < 0.05, respectively]. The 0.4 mL glucose solution had no effect. The 2 mL glucose solution did not attenuate the o(2) increase during venepuncture (1.5 +/- 0.2 mL/kg min (water) versus 1.7 +/- 0.5 (0.4 mL glucose) versus 1.1 +/- 0.2 (2 mL glucose) (mean +/- SEM) nor EE nor heart rate. We conclude that oral administration of 2 mL glucose 30% before venepuncture reduced pain expression and crying, but did not prevent the rise in o(2), EE, or heart rate. Alternative therapies against the stress of nonpainful handling during venepuncture should be explored.

Thermal Thresholds Predict Painfulness of Diabetic Neuropathies

“…The information "pain" represents a stressor causing an arousal of the sympathetic nervous system measurable by HRV (33). A previous study (34) showed that the relief of chronic pain can be followed by an increase in HRV.…”

Effects of Breastfeeding on Pain Relief in Full-term Newborns

“…These include methods such as the ingestion of sucrose [3][4][5] or glucose, 6 skin-to-skin between parent and infant, 7,8 non-nutritive suckling, 9 positioning, 10 and holding. 11 Breastfeeding has also been thought to be useful for relieving pain in neonates.…”

Prevention and Management of Pain in the Neonate: An Update

“…72 Concentrated oral glucose has also been used and diminishes the pain response of venipuncture, but it does not decrease oxygen consumption or energy expenditure, suggesting there may still be a stress response. 85 A wide range of oral sucrose doses have been used in neonates for pain relief, but an optimal dose has not been established. 75,86 The dosage range of sucrose for reducing pain in neonates is 0.012 to 0.12 g (0.05-0.5 mL of 24% solution).…”