Optimum fish passage and guidance designs are based in the hydrogeomorphology of natural rivers

Abstract

Understanding hydrodynamic cues used by outmigrating juvenile salmon (emigrants) to guide fine-scale swim path selection is critical to successful fish guidance and passage at man-made structures. We show how these cues can be inferred from channel features and complex flow fields of natural rivers through which emigrants pass. We then describe a new cue, 'total hydraulic strain', integrating properties of flow acceleration and turbulence through the spatial gradients in velocity to create a single flow field distortion metric amenable to the analysis of fish movement at the scale of large man-made structures. We explain how total hydraulic strain, together with the magnitude of velocity, provide sufficient information for any fish to distinguish between the two categories of channel features with their mechanosensory system. We demonstrate that total hydraulic strain, velocity magnitude and hydrostatic pressure can be integrated into rule-sets (the Strain-Velocity-Pressure (SVP) Hypothesis) to explain emigrant swim path selection near dams. To confirm the reasonableness of the SVP Hypothesis, we describe how its separate elements can be detected by different components of the fish mechanosensory system. We evaluate the SVP Hypothesis by (1) using it to explain the traces made by acoustically tagged emigrants overlaid on coincident total hydraulic strain and velocity magnitude fields, (2) using it to explain different passage efficiencies of competing bypass designs and (3) testing it via stepwise discriminant analysis to infer the relationship between hydrodynamic pattern and emigrant orientation. We conclude the SVP Hypothesis is a reasonable and useful approximation of the strategy used by emigrants to select their swim path through complex flow fields sufficient to serve as the basis of guidance and bypass system design. Published in

Tracking animals in freshwater with electronic tags: past, present and future

“…Recently, the first example of combining genomic studies with field telemetry of Pacific salmon identified the factors that are associated with migration failure in freshwater [143]. Integration of fish telemetry with detailed hydrodynamic studies has been used to optimize fish passage facilities through improved understanding of fish cognition and behaviour [144]. The number of such integrative studies appears to be increasing.…”

Linking individual behaviour and migration success inSalmo salarsmolts approaching a water withdrawal site: implications for management

“…A number of studies have reported Pacific salmon smolts performing milling behaviours in anthropogenically altered channels (Venditti et al 2000;Plumb et al 2006;Nestler et al 2008). The present study showed that milling behaviours also occur in Atlantic salmon smolts (Fig.…”

“…This study is among the first to quantify the behaviour of downstream migrating smolts using high resolution telemetry (Ehrenberg and Steig 2003;Goodwin et al 2006;Nestler et al 2008), particularly in shallow rivers. The results showed that Atlantic salmon smolts performing milling behaviours covered a larger area (m 2 ) (Fig.…”

“…upstream excursions and circular swimming behaviour) in anthropogenically altered channels (Venditti et al 2000;Plumb et al 2006;Nestler et al 2008), however few studies have examined the consequences of these behaviours. The present study had two purposes.…”

Effects of whitewater parks on fish passage: a spatially explicit hydraulic analysis

“…Care should be taken to ensure that velocity and depth requirements are met continuously along likely fish movement paths. Multiple field studies indicate that fish exploit boundary layers created by objects in the flow field (Fausch, 1993;Nestler et al, 2008). Interstitial spaces within the center of the chute may provide zones of lower velocity for smaller fish.…”