Optimization of Drilling Parameters in Drilling of MWCNT-Reinforced GFRP Nanocomposites Using Fuzzy AHP-Weighted Taguchi-Based MCDM Methods

Abstract

Many problems such as delamination, cracking, fiber tearing, ovality, and surface roughness are encountered in the drilling of glass-fiber-reinforced composite (GFRP) materials. In this study, the percentage of multi-walled carbon nano tube (MWCNT), cutting tool type, feed rate, and cutting speed were selected as control factors during the drilling of MWCNT-reinforced GFRP nanocomposites. The quality characteristics of the drilling process were determined as surface roughness, delamination, torque, and thrust force. The experiments were carried out in accordance with the Taguchi L27 orthogonal array. The lowest values obtained because of the experiments were Ra = 4.95 µm, Dm = 1.099, T = 14.78 N, and F = 44.24 N, respectively. However, since each of these outputs were obtained from different experimental trials, different multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) methods were used to optimize all outputs at the same time. First, the criteria were weighted using the fuzzy AHP method, and then the outputs were optimized using multi-criteria decision-making methods (i.e., GRA, WASPAS and VIKOR). Very close optimal ranking was obtained in all three methods. The best results were obtained for Ra = 4.86 µm, Dm = 1.13, T = 55.57 N, and F = 48.00 N. In the next step, the performance values obtained from each MCDM method were re-optimized using the Taguchi S/N ratio method. By comparing between these models, a single optimal condition for drilling is proposed. Accordingly, A2B3C1D1 (Ra = 4.86 µm, Dm = 1.10, T = 17.47 N and F = 48.33 N) for FAHP-GRA and FAHP-WASPAS and A2B3C2D2 (Ra = 5.02 µm, Dm = 1.09, T = 37.19 N and F = 45.01 N) for FAHP-VIKOR were determined as the best performing experiments. Finally, validation tests were conducted to compare the performance of the experiments. As a result, the FAHP-GRA and FAHP-WASPAS optimization with Taguchi S/N gave an unweighted improvement of 82.9% and a weighted improvement of 10.04% compared to the results of the experiment with MCDM. Compared to the results of the experiments with MCDM, S/N FAHP-VIKOR provided an unweighted improvement of 52.75% and a weighted improvement of 8.19%. According to the results obtained, for this study, FAHP-GRA and FAHP-WASPAS are more effective optimization methods than FAHP-VIKOR.

Enhancing Sustainability Through Drilling Machine Efficiency: A Comparative Analysis of TOPSIS and VIKOR Methods for Energy Optimization

“…In comparing our study's findings with existing literature, it's evident that our results corroborate the effectiveness of MCDM methods in optimizing drilling processes It is in line with the studies conducted in the studies [24] and [26]. Specifically, our use of TOPSIS and VIKOR methods for evaluating drilling efficiency mirrors the approach by the study [27], who also applied MCDM techniques in a mining context.…”

“…MCDM methods, recently applied in various fields, enhance the comprehensiveness and robustness of assessment systems [17][18][19][20]. Few studies on drilling machines have integrated MCDM methods [21][22][23][24].…”

An Experimental Analysis of Taguchi-Based Gray Relational Analysis, Weighted Gray Relational Analysis, and Data Envelopment Analysis Ranking Method Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Approaches to Multiple-Quality Characteristic Optimization in the CNC Drilling Process

“…The determination of the weighting value for the j-th criterion is typically contingent upon the structure of the proposed problem or the discretion of the users, as per the context of applications. If it is known how much each weight criterion is worth, then the gray correlation coefficient can be calculated by multiplying the gray correlation coefficient of the criterion with its weight, as stated in [41]. A greater value of the GRG indicates a more favorable degree of correspondence with the ideal data sequence and would be selected as the optimal solution.…”