Opportunities and Challenges in Public Health Data Collection in Southern Asia: Examples from Western India and Kathmandu Valley, Nepal

Abstract

Small-scale local data resources may serve to provide a highly resolved estimate of health effects, which can be spatially heterogeneous in highly populated urban centers in developing countries. We aim to highlight the challenges and opportunities of health data registries in a developing world context. In western India, government-collected daily mortality registry data were obtained from five cities, along with daily hospital admissions data from three government hospitals in Ahmedabad. In Nepal, individual-level data on hospital admissions were collected from six major hospitals in Kathmandu Valley. Our process illustrates many challenges for researchers, governments, and record keepers inherent to data collection in developing countries: creating and maintaining a centralized record-keeping system; standardizing the data collected; obtaining data from some local agencies; assuring data completeness and availability of back-ups to the datasets; as well as translating, cleaning, and comparing data within and across localities. We suggest that these "small-data" resources may better serve the analysis of health outcomes than exposure-response functions extrapolated from data collected in other areas of the world.

Advancing our Understanding of Heat Wave Criteria and Associated Health Impacts to Improve Heat Wave Alerts in Developing Country Settings

“…These data, which do not provide details on cause of death, were collated into all-cause aggregated daily mortality data for each of the communities of interest. To our knowledge, this is the first such compilation of detailed registry date for multiple Indian communities for the purpose of epidemiologic analysis and public health [14]. Data collection was approved by the Yale University Human Subjects Committee (HSC# 1405014004).…”

“…Another study found low levels of short-term mortality displacement in a subset of districts in New Delhi when compared with total mortalities in London and São Paolo [13]. There are many challenges to conducting multi-city regional studies in India, such as a lack of data availability for public health research [14].…”

The Scope and Functions of Health Information Management in e-Health

“…For instance, studies based on some states in India points out the disparity in the type of administrative data included in the datasets, which are mentioned as varying by city, and the study observes lack of professionalism in health care data management. (23). For data extraction from EHR to registries, various challenges are existing regarding the selection of denominators and variables for registries.…”

An examination of long-term variations in mortalities caused by Heat waves occurring in India: an investigation of 50 years data, 19732022

“…Lack of health data is a major obstacle to the research of heat waves and wellness in developing nation settings. Standardized procedures for gathering health data for the objective of conducting health research may not exist in these regions (Nori-Sarma et al, 2017). It is also difficult to extrapolate exposure-response functions from earlier studies, which are predominantly based in the US & Europe with diverse populations and residential features, into environments with high ambient temperatures, especially India.…”