Operatives’ experiences of cultural diversity on Australian construction sites

Abstract

Construction sites are among Australia’s most culturally diverse workplaces. A survey of 1155 construction operatives on Australian construction sites investigated, for the first time, the extent of this diversity and how it is experienced by workers. Results show that while cultural diversity presents organizational challenges by segregating the workforce, operatives’ cultural groups also perform positive functions such as maintaining positive bonds among group members and providing group support and safe havens. While there broadly appears to be equality of opportunity for all cultural groups, there is significant evidence of differential treatment for some groups, particularly in relation to accessing higher paying jobs, offensive graffiti and racist joke telling. Language barriers are one of the major challenges affecting work and social relations between different cultural groups and there is evidence that this has a detrimental impact upon safety.Diversity, culture, immigrants, safety, racism, discrimination,

Site operatives’ attitudes towards traditional masculinity ideology in the Australian construction industry

“…Sample structureMale respondents dominated the sample (94.9%) closely reflecting ABS (2012) statistics around female representation at construction trade level. While a range of ethnic groups were represented, most respondents were of Anglo Saxon/Australian background (51.9%), which contrasts with previous studies of ethnicity byLoosemore et al (2010) (also supported by the CFMEU) which shows high representations from other ethnic groups such as Asians. The sample contained a good balance of age groups and reflects Australian Government statistics which…”

“…Table 6 illustrates the One way ANOVA results for duration of experience in the industry. (Loosemore et al 2010) and these results were somewhat surprising given that attitudes towards masculinity are well known to vary between cultural and ethnic groups (Hofstede 1984) and as Datta (2009:4) notes, "masculinities are understood to be produced from their mutually constitutive relationships with other identities of class, race, nationality, and ethnicity that operate in different places. "…”

Impact of national culture on knowledge sharing in international construction projects

“…Communication is the activity that is mostly influenced by national culture (Loosemore et al 2010). Many participants identified communication as the major problem in knowledge sharing among different cultures.…”

The impact of cultural diversity on the effectiveness of construction project teams

“…McCuiston et al (2004) argued that diversity can improve companies' bottom line by improving corporate culture, improving relationships with clients, retaining talented employees, decreasing complaints, and improving employee morale. Although the creation of cultural "enclaves" within organisations can provide the space where cultural, minority, groups find social support and networking it is seen to weaken links and cohesion with other cultural groups (Loosemore et al 2010). Seymen (2006) review of the relevant literature led him to conclude that cultural diversity is an important tool for competitive superiority for organisations and therefore they should be supported.…”