Operative Planning in Thoracic Surgery: A Pilot Study Comparing Imaging Techniques and Three-Dimensional Printing

Abstract

Background: Careful preoperative planning in thoracic surgery is essential for positive outcomes especially in video assisted thoracic surgery (VATS) where palpation and 3-dimensional imaging is restricted. The objective of this study was to evaluate the ability of different imaging techniques such as Computerized Tomography (CT) scanning, maximal intensity projection (MIP) imaging, 3dimensional (3D) reconstruction as well as 3D printing, to define the anatomy of the hilar structures prior to anatomical lung resection. Methods: All patients undergoing elective lung resections by VATS for cancer under a single surgeon were identified over a three-month period. A single surgeon was asked to record the number of pulmonary artery branches supplying the lobe to be resected using the preoperative CT scan, MIP images and 3D reconstructed CT images. 3 patients had their lung hilum printed. These were then compared to the intraoperative findings. Results: 16 patients had their preoperative imaging analyzed. A further 3 patients had their lung hilum 3D printed. Although not statistically significant, the 3D prints of the hilum were found to be the most accurate measurement with a correlation of 0.92. CT, 3D reconstructed CT and MIP images tended to under recognize the number of arterial branches and therefore scored between 0.26 and 0.39 in terms of absolute agreement with the number of arteries found at operation. Conclusions: 3D printing in the planning of thoracic surgery may suggest a benefit over contemporary available imaging modalities and the use of 3D printing in practicing operations is being established.

3D printed bismuth oxide‐polylactic acid composites for radio‐mimetic computed tomography spine phantoms

“…Applications include prosthetics, 4,5 anatomical models for surgical planning, 6,7 and education 8‐13 . The ability of AM to produce highly customized anatomical models that can not only be visualized but also manipulated in three dimensions by touch has shown promise as a valuable tool in diverse medical fields ranging from neurosurgery, 14,15 orthopedics, 16,17 otolaryngology, 18 and cardiothoracic surgery 19 . These devices and models can often be printed directly from, or in concert with, computed tomography (CT) images of patient anatomy 20 .…”

Three-dimensional reconstruction/personalized three-dimensional printed model for thoracoscopic anatomical partial-lobectomy in stage I lung cancer: a retrospective study

“…In fact, to design margin or intersegmental line before operation by using 3D reconstruction is a critical step in APL. Current researches are limited to preoperative planning using 3D reconstruction and simulation (23). There is no in-depth study on the guidance of intra-operation.…”

A review and guide to creating patient specific 3D printed anatomical models from MRI for benign gynecologic surgery

“…Furthermore, these 3D digital models can be converted into tangible, physical models by way of 3D printing [ 8 , 9 ]. Rather than 3D visualization where a volumetric model is viewed on a 2D computer screen, a 3D printed model can provide a real indication of depth and tactile feedback, thus allowing surgeons to develop a clearer understanding of surgical anatomy [ 10 , 11 ]. With a better visualization of disease location relative to adjacent organs, surgeons utilising 3D printed models for pre-operative planning have been shown to have greater surgical outcomes including, decreased operative time [ 12 – 14 ], blood loss [ 12 , 13 ], and incision length [ 13 ].…”