Operation Coffeecup: Ronald Reagan, Rugged Individualism, and the Debate over “Socialized Medicine”

Abstract

In 1961, the American Medical Association (AMA) funded a persuasive campaign called Operation Coffeecup. The campaign, which was designed to defeat Medicare, featured a speech by a young Ronald Reagan outlining the dangers of “socialized medicine.” The speech was recorded on a long-play record and distributed to the Women’s Auxiliary of the AMA, a group primarily composed of the wives of doctors who were instructed to write seemingly spontaneous letters to Congress detailing their opposition to the program. This essay investigates Operation Coffeecup mainly through a rhetorical analysis of Reagan’s speech. I argue that “socialized medicine” drew upon a problematic articulation of American culture that privileges the individual at the expense of the larger community. I conclude by discussing the thread of individualism that has persisted in the United States from the pre-Depression era mythos of rugged individualism to neoliberal discourses that shape debates about health policy today.

Enhancing cultural safety among undergraduate nursing students through watching documentaries

“…We have so many luxuries and food, water, shelter, while others have none’ (participant 24). Lastly, for some students, the documentary God Grew Tired of Us perpetuated deeply held beliefs common in the United States with regard to the notion of ‘rugged individualism.’ Individualism became touted as a pillar of American society with the rise of neoliberalism (Onge, ). In neoliberal discourses, individuals are responsible for their own fate and capitalism provides the mechanism to achieve success (Bray & Schommer‐Aikins, ).…”

“…Based on our analysis, the students often did not take into account their own social location and its privileges, and made as- American society with the rise of neoliberalism (Onge, 2017). In neoliberal discourses, individuals are responsible for their own fate and capitalism provides the mechanism to achieve success (Bray & Schommer-Aikins, 2016).…”

Missing pieces: Integrating the socialist world in global health history

“…Health systems and access to healthcare were particular sticking points in the Cold War era, and became central to the international governance of health by the 1970s, and it is unsurprising that we find much of the interventions in this field. From American concerns over the question of socialized medicine, as a threat to free‐market capitalism and a vehicle for the Red Scare (Onge, 2017), to the active seeking of working socialist healthcare models by new revolutionary states, such as Cuba, certain aspects of health care provision became emblematic political calling cards. One of these, the issue of primary health care became a key approach as disease eradication campaigns and top‐down technical solutions faltered.…”