Operating in a Constricted Space: Policy Actor Perceptions of Targeting to Address U.S. Health Disparities

Abstract

Policy actors design and implement targeted interventions to eliminate disparities that exist between groups. Although necessary for achieving health equity, the use of targeting as a policy tool carries the potential for political backlash and social debate, which may influence whether and how policy actors use it. In this research, the authors examine policy actor perceptions regarding the use of targeting in the implementation of health policy. The authors conduct elite interviews with policy actors to better understand their work to design and implement interventions to address health disparities. Findings identify key tensions and trade-offs faced by policy actors related to targeting and reveal sociopolitical influences that shape whether and how targeted programs are considered, who receives them, and by what means they are delivered. The authors discuss the implications of the findings for the use of targeting and related marketing practices by policy actors to address health disparities and other significant public health concerns.

Transformative Service Initiatives: Enabling Access and Overcoming Barriers for People Experiencing Vulnerability

“…Public policymakers often only support refugee integration initiatives for a limited time, which may prove inefficient in terms of resource allocations and cannot support long-term capacity building (Mangan and Winter 2017). Based on our finding of positive, measurable effects of TSI for refugees, we recommend that public policymakers ensure the targeting and the mid- to long-term funding of such initiatives (Grier and Schaller 2020). Moreover, considering the wide variety of TSIs needed, we recommend a network approach (Boenigk et al 2021).…”

School Nurses Matter: Relationship Between School Nurse Employment Policies and Chronic Health Condition Policies in U.S. School Districts

“…An additional challenge regarding the existence of district-level policies involving both school nurse employment and CHCs is the lack of strategic guidance on addressing targeted population priorities and overall population/community health. In this regard, Grier and Schaller (2020) highlight how stakeholders perceive that strategic documents, such as Healthy People 2020 (U.S. Department of Health and Human Services [HHS], 2017) and the HHS Disparities Action Plan (HHS, 2011), offer minimal guidelines to operationalize and implement suggested policies. Thus, when there are no specific guidelines, direction, or enforcement, the school district is left to design policies and practice procedures on their own or, in some cases, not develop policies at all.…”

Will Social Marketing Fight for Black Lives? An Open Letter to the Field

“…Moreover, racism as a social pathology affects not only racial “minorities,” but all individuals in society. For example, researchers found that policy actors may be reluctant to target interventions to address health disparities based on concerns of appearing racist to constituents and inciting public feedback (Grier & Schaller, 2020). Such attitudes and behaviors may interfere in the development of social marketing interventions and will need to be addressed in order to pursue the best actions.…”