Opening the black box of transfer systems in public sector health services in a Western state in India

Abstract

BackgroundLimited research on Posting and Transfer (P&T) policies and systems in the public sector health services and the reluctance for an open debate on the issue makes P&T as a black box. Limited research on P&T in India suggests that P&T policies and systems are either non-existent, weak, poorly implemented or characterized by corruption. Hence the current study aimed at opening the “black box” of P&T systems in public sector health services in India by assessing the implementation gaps between P&T policies and their actual implementation.MethodsThis was a qualitative study carried out in Department of Health, in a Western State in India. To understand the extant P&T policies, a systems map was first developed with the help of document review and Key Informant (KI) Interviews. Next systems audit was carried out to assess the actual implementation of transfer policies by interviewing Medical Officers (MOs), the group mainly affected by the P&T policies. Job histories were constructed from the interviews to understand transfer processes like frequencies of transfers and to assess if transfer rules were adhered. The analysis is based on a synthesis of document review, 19 in-depth interviews with MOs working with state health department and five in-depth interviews with Key Informants (KIs). Framework analysis approach was used to analyze data using NVIVO.ResultsThe state has a generic transfer guideline applicable to all government officers but there is no specific transfer policy or guideline for government health personnel. The generic transfer guidelines are weakly implemented indicating a significant gap between policy and actual implementation. The formal transfer guidelines are undermined by a parallel system in which desirable posts are attained, retained or sometimes given up by the use of political connections and money. MOs’ experiences of transfers were marked by perceptions of unfairness and irregularities reflected through interviews as well as the job histories.DiscussionThe generic transfer rules and ambiguity in how transfers are treated may explain the discrepancy between policy and implementation leading to systems abuse. This discrepancy could have negative influence on MOs’ morale which could in turn affect distribution of MOs. Where possible, ambiguity in the rules should be avoided and a greater transparency on implementation of the transfer rules is needed. However, it may not be possible to make any significant improvements to P&T policies and how they are implemented until the external pressure that creates parallel systems is greatly reduced in translating HR policy into HR practice.ConclusionsEffective P&T policies and implementation may have important implications for organizational performance and may help to improve Human Resource (HR) policy and HR expertise. Also there is a greater need for transparency on implementation of the rules. However, it may not be possible to make any significant improvements to P&T policies and how they are implemented until the external pressure that ...

Preparedness of primary and secondary health facilities in India to address major noncommunicable diseases: results of a National Noncommunicable Disease Monitoring Survey (NNMS)

“…Our study shows that some PHCs reported availability of specialists also. These must be upgraded PHCs or even CHCs serving additionally as a PHC or it also indicates inappropriate posting policy of the doctors not commensurate with their training that has been documented earlier [ 33 ]. Additionally, human resource allocations are usually influenced by health policies and disease epidemiology at sub-national and local levels.…”

Flexibility of deployment: challenges and policy options for retaining health workers during crisis in Zimbabwe

“…The pragmatic response of the district-level managers was to be flexible in the use of the transfer rules aiming more at retaining HWs than to ensure equitable staffing of health facilities. Here, flexibility was used in a positive way, though elsewhere flexible interpretation of rules may be seen as negative [32]. However, secondment was used as an alternative and temporary way of filling vacancies.…”

WITHDRAWN: Experience and reflections of using individual work histories and events of public sector doctors to unpack Human Resource Management policies and systems: Job histories as powerful method in Human Resource for Health research

“…The authors' previous experience in conducting HRH related research suggests there are gaps between HRH policy and its implementation, and the expectations of doctors. Health Policy and Systems Research (HPSR), specifically around HRM policies and systems suggests similar issues where such policies and systems are perceived to be bureaucratic, slow, sporadic, 'mission inconsistent', open to corruption, and disrupting career trajectories for doctors (3)(4)(5)(6)(7). Hence HRH related policy implementation and the methods that can examine it in public health sector is a critical that needs attention.…”

“…Job or 'work' histories have been used in disciplines such as hospitality (9), labour market analysis (10) and health sector, more specifically occupational and environmental health (11,12). Some HRH related research also exist that use job histories as a method to examine the policy implementation (5,6,13).…”