Online PBL: a route to sustainability education?

Abstract

Purpose -The purpose of this paper is to investigate online problem-based learning (PBL) as a route to achieving sustainability education using sponsored projects. Design/methodology/approach -The Royal Academy of Engineering sponsored project at Manchester; to foster education in sustainability through inter-disciplinary problem-based approaches, has since been extended to other groups and to a broader array of issues. One of the limiting factors is the ease with which this approach can be taken in the case of large numbers of students and a commensurate requirement for large numbers of facilitators. The University of Keele, together with partners from the universities of Manchester and Staffordshire, was awarded National Teaching Fellowship Scheme funding to explore further the use of blended or online approaches, in order to overcome these limitations. The pilot unit already has a certain amount of support using the BlackBoard virtual learning environment (VLE) but this scenario is supposed to rely entirely on online working. At the time of writing, the evaluation of the pilot has not been completed but an online questionnaire was devised to monitor students' reactions to the online working and to ascertain whether they did in fact work entirely online or whether they chose to meet informally face-to-face. Difficulties encountered were both organizational (mostly relating to enrolment) and technical (this was a new version of BlackBoard and had a few teething troubles). Findings -This pilot project has demonstrated that a blended approach to PBL is feasible. There are some forms of resistance from students. The assessment was outcomes-driven rather than processdriven. This meant that it was not necessary for the academic staff to have access to all the discussions, thus acting as facilitators. There is a general theme that while learners found it possible to work effectively as a group online, they also found it more difficult. It is possible that the students were having to dedicate more time and effort to the use of the online system, which had an impact on their creativity and productivity. Research limitations/implications -In the case of the University of Manchester, the developments are being applied to a Masters-level course unit in Managing Humanitarian Aid Projects. This unit proceeds on the basis of five scenarios that students try to resolve in small groups and in the first pilot year one of these scenarios is being delivered on-line. Practical implications -The results of this pilot could be fed in to different stages of programme deployment to examine impact and explore possibilities with distance learning modules. Originality/value -This paper has looked at the effectiveness of nationally run, problem-based learning projects that are aimed at improving understanding, engagement and deployment on diverse learning environments to include VLEs.

To what extent can PBL principles be applied in blended learning: Lessons learned from health master programs

“…The principles contain that learning should be constructive, selfdirected, collaborative, and contextual. All case studies in the present study show that both synchronous (real time) and asynchronous PBL variants were feasible, which is in line with previous studies (Savin-Baden 2007; Tomkinson & Hutt 2012). In case 1, the implementation of PBL principles was the most extensive.…”

Which conditions facilitate the effectiveness of large-group learning activities? A systematic review of research in higher education

“…As such, a large-group compared to a small one, should not necessarily show differences in students' learning outcomes, as long as all students are motivated and engaged in the learning process (Goodman et al 2005). The latter is possible if relevant cognitive interactions within the activities are promoted by the teaching staff (Cahill et al, 2014;Tomkinson & Hutt, 2012), which have the potential to support and enhance motivation (Denker, 2013;Exeter et al, 2010;Hejmadi, 2007). • Engage with teachers, professionals or students from other countries through videoconferences.…”

Driving education for sustainable development potential within professional curricula: Built environment sustainability training and training development for professionals in Wales

“…In addition, the programme is developing a fully online course aimed at outlining what sustainability is and why it is important for built environment professionals. Current literature on online approaches to ESD based learning is limited, although there is suggestion from Tomkinson and Hutt (2012) that a blended approach to problem-based learning is feasible with some associated difficulties (including group work difficulties). Indeed, current uptake on this course is limited, but it is anticipated that this becomes a 'legacy' of BEST, being available after the core funding has ceased.…”