One and Done: The Long Eclipse of Women’s Televised Sports, 1989–2019

Abstract

For 3 decades we have tracked and analyzed the quantity and quality of coverage of women’s and men’s sports in televised news and highlights shows. In this paper, we report on our most recent iteration of the longitudinal study, which now includes an examination of online sports newsletters and social media. The study reveals little change in the quantitative apportionment of coverage of women’s and men’s sports over the past 30 years. Men’s sports—especially the “Big Three” of basketball, football and baseball—still receive the lion’s share of the coverage, whether in-season or out of season. When a women’s sports story does appear, it is usually a case of “one and done,” a single women’s sports story obscured by a cluster of men’s stories that precede it, follow it, and are longer in length. Social media posts and online sports newsletters’ coverage, though a bit more diverse in some ways, mostly reflected these same patterned gender asymmetries. Gender-bland sexism continued as the dominant pattern in 2019 TV news and highlights’ stories on women’s sports. Three themes of this “gender-bland” coverage include: 1) nationalism, 2) asymmetrical gender marking coupled with local parochialism, and 3) community service/ charitable contributions.

Sports, Transgender Rights and the Bodily Politics of Cisgender Supremacy

“…In addition to establishing a fraught context for the full inclusion of transgender athletes, segregation enables unequal support for and value of women's sports. Sports for girls and women remain severely under-funded (Staurowsky et al 2020), opportunities for women in coaching and athletic leadership have substantially decreased in the past decades (Sabo et al 2016;Whisenant 2003), female athletes remain vulnerable to sexual harassment and abuse (Macur and Levenson 2021;Novkov 2019), media coverage of women's sports falls well below that of men's (Cooky et al 2021), and when women athletes are covered it is more likely to be through sexualizing frames (Musto et al 2017;Musto and McGann 2016).…”

Public service media, sports and cultural citizenship in the age of social media: An analysis of BBC Sport agenda diversity on Twitter

“…For decades, scholarly research has deeply discussed the long-standing minimisation of sportswomen in day-to-day media coverage, highlighting that such underrepresentation is a consequence of cultural male hegemony in the sports world (Hardin, Dodd and Lauffer, 2006;Schell and Rodriguez, 2000). Across media platforms, the resulting coverage of leading female athletes and teams is still regarded as marginal compared to the frequency of appearances of their male counterparts (Coche, 2015;Cooky et al, 2021;Schoch, 2020). This gendered imbalance in the sports agenda is particularly important because it reinforces old cultural and androcentric stereotypes and acts as a barrier to promoting female role models in society (O'Neill and Mulready, 2015).…”

Brief Research Report: “Nothing About Us, Without Us”: A Case Study of the Outer Sanctum Podcast and Trends in Australian Independent Media to Drive Intersectional Representation

“…Studies conducted over the last 30 years have consistently found the representation of women working in sports newsrooms is close to 10% (Henningham, 1995 ; Whiteside and Hardin, 2006 ; Nicholson et al, 2011 ), while women's sports coverage accounts for <10% (Lumby et al, 2014 ; Cooky et al, 2015 , 2021 ). Further, when women's sport is covered, rather than being prioritized, it is generally treated as secondary, or peripheral to men's sport.…”