On the Role of Perception: Understanding Stakeholders’ Collaboration in Natural Resources Management through the Evolutionary Theory of Innovation

Abstract

Natural resources management deals with highly complex socioecological systems. This complexity raises a conundrum, since wide-ranging knowledge from different sources and types is needed, but at the same time none of these types of knowledge is able by itself to provide the basis for a viable productive system, and mismatches between the two of them are common. Therefore, a growing body of literature has examined the integration of different types of knowledge in fisheries management. In this paper, we aim to contribute to this ongoing debate by integrating the evolutionary theory of innovation—and specifically the concept of proximity—and the theory of perception. We set up a theoretical framework that is able to explain not only why the different types of knowledge differ, but also why they should differ and why this divergence is useful to develop fisheries management. This framework is illustrated through a well-known complex scenario, as was the implementation of the Landing Obligation (LO) in Europe. We conclude that diversity (distance) between types of knowledge is essential for interactive learning, innovation, the incorporation of new ideas or to avoid lock-in, etc. At the same time, cognitive, institutional, geographical, etc. proximity is needed for effective communication, participation and dialogue.

Cognitive proximity for innovation: Why matters? an applied analysis

“…A company's ability for innovation is constrained not just by its boundaries, but also by the cognitive proximity achieved in particular places. Some empirical research has revealed cognitive proximity as the main mechanism for the formation of informal knowledge-circulating networks, and then suggesting that innovation outcomes and inter-organizational learning require the existence of social and cognitive proximity among firms [28][29][30].…”

Implementation of Regional Tax Collections in the Tax Sector of Non-Metal Minerals and Rocks That Do Not Have a People's Mining License in the Ogan Ilir District Area

“…The critical role of the Ogan Ilir Regency in the mining sector must be connected to the importance of mining permits [9]. Mining permits are the legal basis that regulates the region's extraction and exploitation activities of natural resources [10], [11]. With a mining permit, local governments can control and supervise mining activities according to applicable regulations.…”

Cognitive social capital for knowledge absorption in specialized environments: The path to innovation

“…However, physical closeness does not always indicate advantages for the companies in a particular location [7]. Innovation generation and inter-organizational learning seem to require, besides geographical closeness, the presence of cognitive proximity and similar social patterns between geographically adjacent experienced economic actors belonging to a main industry, which allows for successful communication [8]. Thus, industrial agglomeration refers to those organizations located close in geographical terms, and with experience in a main sector, which usually present common cognitive and social features.…”