On the High Fluctuations of Received Signal Strength Measurements With BLE Signals for Contact Tracing and Proximity Detection

Abstract

This paper presents a measurement-based analysis of the Received Signal Strength (RSS) of Bluetooth Low Energy (BLE) signals, under Line-of-Sight (LOS) and Non-Line-of-Sight (NLOS) scenarios, performed in tandem at two universities in Tampere, Finland, and Bucharest, Romania. We adopted the same hardware and methodology for measurements in both places, and paid particular attention to the impact of RSS on various environmental factors, such as LOS and NLOS scenarios and interference in 2.4 GHz band. In addition, we considered the receiver orientation and the different frequencies of BLE advertising channels. We show that snapshot RSS measurements typically have high variability, not easily explainable by classical path-loss models. A snapshot recording is defined here as one continuous recording at fixed device locations in a static setup. Our observations also show that aggregated RSS data (i.e., considering several snapshot measurements together) is more informative from a statistical point of view and more in agreement with current theoretical path-loss models than snapshot measurements. However, in BLE applications such as contact tracing and proximity detection, the receivers typically have access only to snapshot measurements (e.g., taken over a short duration of 10-20 minutes or less), so the accuracy of contact-tracing and proximity detection can be highly affected by RSS instabilities. In addition to presenting the measurement-based BLE RSS analysis in a comprehensive and well-documented format, our paper also emphasizes open challenges when BLE RSS is used for contact tracing, ranging, and positioning applications. 3 CH37 CH0 CH1 CH2 CH3 BLE advertising channels BLE data channels 2.4GHz Frequency Band

A Survey of Security in Cloud, Edge, and Fog Computing

“… Location Privacy: Several software and services from Worldwide Web render functional capabilities based on location. For a client to gain access when they want to use the services in Edge computing, that client must deliver their location as required by the service provider [ 77 , 78 ]. One of the particularly concerning fears is breaching data location through possible leaks.…”

A Cross Platform Contact Tracing Mobile Application for COVID-19 Infections using Deep Learning

“…The RSSI is manufacturer dependent and can vary even at a fixed separation between the sending and receiving Bluetooth Low Energy (BLE) devices [35]. Factors such as multipath propagation, scattering, shadowing, refraction among others affect BLE signals and this has implications for applications that rely on BLE such as those for contact tracing [36]. The RSSI can be reasonably mapped to a distance from the sending device on iOS devices.…”

Perturbed-Location Mechanism for Increased User-Location Privacy in Proximity Detection and Digital Contact-Tracing Applications

“…Proximity-detection services based on wireless signals, and in particular based on BLE, have gained a significant interest in the past two years as they are enabling digital contract-tracing techniques [4] shown to be relevant in the context of COVID-19 disease management [5,6]. Magnetic-field proximity detection solutions have also been recently proposed in the context of digital contact tracing, for example, in [7].…”