On the consistency of magnetic field measurements of Ap stars: lessons learned from the FORS1 archive

Abstract

Context. The ESO archive of FORS1 spectropolarimetric observations may be used to create a homogeneous database of magnetic field measurements. However, no systematic comparison of FORS field measurements to those obtained with other instruments has been undertaken so far. Aims. We exploit the FORS archive of circular spectropolarimetric data to examine in a general way how reliable and accurate field detections obtained with FORS are. Methods. We examine the observations of Ap and Bp stars, on the grounds that almost all of the unambiguous detections of magnetic fields in the FORS1 archive are in these kinds of stars. We assess the overall quality of the FORS1 magnetic data by examining the consistency of field detections with what is known from previous measurements obtained with other instruments, and we look at patterns of internal consistency. Results. FORS1 magnetic measurements are fully consistent with those made with other instruments, and the internal consistency of the data is excellent. However, it is important to recognise that each choice of grism and wavelength window constitutes a distinct instrumental measuring system, and that simultaneous field measurements in different instrumental systems may produce field strength values that differ up to 20%, or more. Furthermore, we found that field measurements using hydrogen lines only yield results that meaningfully reflect the field strength as sampled specifically by lines of hydrogen for stars with effective temperatures above about 9000 K. Conclusions. In general the magnetic field measurements of Ap and Bp stars obtained with FORS1 are of excellent quality, accuracy and precision, and FORS1 provides an extremely useful example that offers valuable lessons for field measurements with other low-resolution Cassegrain spectropolarimeters.

HARPS spectropolarimetry of three sharp-lined Herbig Ae stars: New insights

“…This kind of behaviour can likely be explained by the presence of concentration of iron-peak elements in the region of the magnetic equator, similar to the iron A15, page 4 of 9 peak element spot distribution frequently observed in classical Ap stars (see e.g. Landstreet et al 2014). The presence of iron spots was already indicated in previous studies of this star by Hubrig et al (2011bHubrig et al ( , 2012, who presented variability of equivalent width, radial velocity, line width, and line asymmetry using a sample of blend free iron lines.…”

A comprehensive analysis of the magnetic standard star HD 94660: Host of a massive compact companion?

“…The discovery of Co in HD 94660 was surprising and further detailed studies of other hot magnetic Ap stars are recommended to ascertain the overabundance of this element in the atmospheres of these stars. Landstreet et al (2014) highlight the fact that HD 94660 is a star where there is poor agreement between the B z measurements made from instruments with lower and higher resolutions. This is evident in Fig.…”

B field in OB stars (BOB): The outstandingly strong magnetic field in the evolved He-strong star CPD −62° 2124

“…Nonetheless, there is a difference of approximately 600 G between the measurements based on the hydrogen lines, whereas the values are consistent within the errors when the whole spectrum is considered. Such discrepancies for strongly magnetic stars are not uncommon (see Landstreet et al 2014;Fossati et al 2015b).…”