On-Site Sewage Systems from Good to Bad to…? Swedish Experiences with Institutional Change and Technological Dependencies 1900 to 2010

Abstract

Even though technological advances have occurred during recent decades today's nutrient loading from Swedish on-site sewage systems (OSSs) is much higher than in the 1940s, despite a decreased rural population and the existence of potentially far better technologies than the existing inadequate installations. The objective of this paper is first, to explain this situation as the result of co-evolution of technology and institutions, which has resulted in a very stable conservation. Second, to properly understand how such stable configurations may change, the paper investigates how a power-distributional theory of incremental institutional change might complement the previous analysis and open up the thinking about how seemingly stable configurations may change endogenously. The analysis reveals how shifts in the distribution of power, i.e., public and private actors' resources and tools to use in interaction with other actors, have influenced the direction of technological and institutional development. We conclude that the sequencing of events has been important; the series of choices made foremost between the 1950s and 1990s caused both institutional and technical lock-in effects that have been increasingly difficult to break out from. Despite parallel and later incremental developments, improvement in the environmental outcome is not yet seen on the large scale. OPEN ACCESSSustainability 2013, 5 4707

Capturing emergent phenomena in social-ecological systems: an analytical framework

“…the installment of new sewage treatment technology which is a high cost investment, however, depends on enforcement measures and how individual house owners were involved in the regulation process (Enforcement AS). In this case enforcement was carried out through visits of representatives of the municipality to house owners (Wallin et al 2013). As the lake was already in a turbid state, the municipality engaged in bio-manipulation, i.e.…”

Combining system dynamics and agent-based modeling to analyze social-ecological interactions—an example from modeling restoration of a shallow lake

“…But since the use of fertilizer has been regulated and municipal sewage treatment has been technically upgraded, private house owners and their aggregated impact have now a significant influence on lake nutrient levels. They are thus important actors to decrease today's nutrient input to the lake by upgrading their onsite-sewage systems (OSS) (Wallin et al, 2013b). Before the aggregated impact from private sewage treatment affects the lake, house owners decide individually whether or not to upgrade their private system and their decision is for instance influenced by the current legislation.…”

“…The development of the social submodel has been inspired by the model of Tavoni et al (2012) which investigates the role of social disapproval for successful cooperation. We explore two different mechanisms of how this willingness to upgrade could be influenced based on evidence from a recent survey among Swedish house owners (Wallin et al, 2013b). When confronting house owners with the request to upgrade their sewage system, they find themselves in a high-cost low-benefit situation.…”