On Masculinities, Technologies, and Pain: The Testing of Male Contraceptives in the Clinic and the Media

Abstract

In the last fifteen years, testing has attracted much attention in science and technology studies. Most researchers have focused almost exclusively on testing in the laboratory, specifically designed test locations, and, for medical technologies, the clinic. What counts as testing has largely been described in terms of the activities of scientific experts. This is not to say that science and technology studies have completely neglected other institutional discourses. Journalistic texts have been a favorite research site for scholars in science and technology studies, particularly those seeking to understand the dynamics of public controversies on science and technology. Although most constructivist studies of science and media relations have treated journalistic texts as secondary to scientific texts, other scholars have dismissed this hierarchy. In this article, scientific texts and journalistic texts are considered equally important locations in which to analyze the testing of technologies. Based on a case study on the testing of a new contraceptive technology for men, the article shows that what counts as successful testing is not solely in the hands of scientific experts. In the case of male contraceptive technologies, journalists have contested the claims of scientific experts, particularly their claims about the cultural feasibility of the new technology.Let me begin with a reflection on my own research practice. Last spring I had planned to begin writing a book on the constraints on the development of 265 AUTHOR'S NOTE: I would like to thank

Disconnecting with Social Networking Sites

“…Of course, Akrich acknowledges these preferred readings may be adapted, edited or indeed rewritten. In a similar vein, Woolgar (1991) discussed designers' attempts to configure the user and how this might constrain appropriation though this position has been subject to critique as overemphasising the power of designers (Wajcman 1991, Berg and Lie 1995, Oudshoorn 1999, Mackay et al 2000. In contrast, the downplaying of designers and the emphasis upon users is well articulated within the key work of Roger Silverstone regarding processes of domestication (Silverstone 1996(Silverstone , 2006.…”

Sociología de la práctica médica autoritaria: violencia obstétrica, anticoncepción inducida y derechos reproductivos

“…La baja prevalencia de vasectomías puede deberse, en parte, como sugieren algunos estudios, a los prejuicios en torno de este procedimiento, entre los que sobresalen creencias que relacionan la esterilización masculina con una disminución de la virilidad (Vernon, 1996;Ringheim, 2002;Oudshoorn, 1999;. Pero esencialmente se explica por el efecto de la asignación diferencial de responsabilidades a varones y mujeres en distintos ámbitos de la vida cotidiana y en particular en la reproducción, expresión del orden corporal hegemónico que refleja y condiciona las decisiones reproductivas y las orientaciones médicas sobre la materia (Bush, 2000).…”

La contraception masculine médicalisée : enjeux psychosociaux et craintes imaginaires

“…Tenter de l'expliquer uniquement par des arguments relatifs au manque de progrès technique, technologique ou médical serait aussi illusoire que de prétendre comprendre le phénomène « Viagra » purement du point de vue pharmaceutique. Dans le cadre de cet article nous opterons pour une approche compréhensive des discours autour d'une (hypothétique) contraception masculine médicalisée sous l'angle des représentations sociales du corps et de la santé (Jodelet, 2006a, Kalampalikis, 2006, des identités et des logiques de la domination masculine (Héritier, 1999 ;Oudshoorn, 1999).…”