On considering climate resilience in urban water security: A review of the vulnerability of the urban poor in sub‐Saharan Africa

Abstract

Climate shock-related water insecurity has a significant impact on poverty, and vice versa, with poor people adversely impacted by different hazards. Many studies have focused on rural communities resulting in a lack of evidence on the vulnerability of urban dwellers. In this review, we explore the literature on the vulnerability of the urban poor to floods, droughts, and cholera in Sub-Saharan Africa. We particularly highlight the structural challenges and systemic inequalities that are increasing the vulnerability of the urban poor including the differential experiences of women and children. We conclude that poor people have: unequal opportunities to cope with shocks, being deprived from access to water services that wealthier households have; their needs are inequitably ignored; and cumulative vulnerability that reverberates climate shocks into smaller consequences that can have dramatic effects. Therefore, the pathways out of poverty are limited for the urban poor. This is not only due to factors of political economy such as the location and construction materials of houses, but also legacies of discrimination and their reproduction. Individual vulnerabilities are frequently increased due to the roles and responsibilities assigned to people of particular genders and/or ages. We find that these differential vulnerabilities are crucial yet poorly researched. There is also a lack of evidence for the manifold effects of drought on the urban poor. Building on the urban climate resilience literature we argue that policy makers and practitioners must consider who water security is for.

Costs, Climate and Contamination: Three Drivers for Citywide Sanitation Investment Decisions

“…Climate change does not affect everyone equally, and low-income households are more likely to be in areas affected by sewage and septage overflow during floods (Hawkins et al, 2013). Low-income households are also more likely to use precarious sanitation systems that are easily destroyed or disrupted by climate hazards, and they typically possess the least capacity to cope with and adapt to shocks (Grasham et al, 2019). Urban sanitation decisions must take account of the differential impacts of climate change across social groups and their capacity to respond to those impacts.…”

Geographical inequalities in drinking water in the Solomon Islands

“…Unplanned and unimproved water service delivery in densely populated peri-urban and informal settlements is particularly problematic when considering the impact of extreme weather events such as heavy rains, flooding and drought on drinking water and sanitation infrastructure and resulting exposure to infectious diseases in the Solomon Islands (Fleming et al 2019, Grasham et al 2019, Howard et al 2010, Howard et al 2016, Jenkins and Jupiter 2015, McDonald et al 2011, MID 2014, Tucci 2008, WHO 2015.…”

“…The choice of household drinking water source is closely related to seasonality, amongst other factors. Unpredictable and changing precipitation patterns make rainwater -one of the main drinking water sources in the Solomon Islands -an unreliable source, inducing seasonal shifts in domestic water source use and storage during periods of reduced rainfall and drought (Elliott et al 2017, Foster and Willetts 2018, Grasham et al 2019, Hadwen et al 2015, Mosley et al 2004, Smith 2008. Inclusion of data on seasonality and multiple source use could have allowed for deeper and more contextualized insights, and for an increased understanding of how a "portfolio" of sources can reveal resiliency to water insecurity (Elliott et al 2017, Anthonj and Brocklehurst 2019).…”

COVID-19 and the call for ‘Safe Hands’: Challenges facing the under-resourced municipalities that lack potable water access - A case study of Chitungwiza municipality, Zimbabwe

“…In Africa, 400 million people lack access to clean water. 2 African cities are also facing increasing water insecurity ( Grasham et al., 2019 ). The COVID-19 pandemic exacerbates this situation.…”