Let M be a compact, orientable, @-irreducible 3-manifold and F be a connected closed essential surface in M with g.F / 1 which cuts M into M 1 and M 2 . In the present paper, we show the following theorem: Suppose that there is no essential surface with boundary .As a consequence, we further show that if M i has a Heegaard splittingThe main results follow from a new technique which is a stronger version of Schultens'