Tectonic models that account for the occurrence of eclogite, retrograde eclogite, peridotite, and migmatitic basement gneisses in the southern Blue Ridge invoke closure of a small ocean basin between the eastern Blue Ridge (EBR) and western Blue Ridge (WBR). In this “obducted ophiolite” model, Franciscan‐type, eastward subduction of oceanic crust beneath the Piedmont arc occurred prior to obduction of the arc onto the Laurentian margin. The discovery of kilometer‐scale eclogite bodies near the EBR‐WBR boundary are cited as evidence for obducted ophiolite/accreted island arc models. However, thermobarometric estimates based on mineral chemistry from HP metabasites of the western, central, and eastern Blue Ridge indicate that eclogites and granulites are medium‐temperature type (550–900°C), inconsistent with the obducted ophiolite model. Mid‐ocean ridge basalt subducted beneath continental margins and island arcs rarely reaches temperatures in excess of 550°C. Thermobarometric comparisons of the present study and a reexamination of deep seismic profiles from the Blue Ridge allow for a model of westward subduction of continental material beneath Laurentia during the Taconic orogeny that produced a megamélange now preserved in the central and eastern Blue Ridge tectonic provinces. P‐T paths determined from Blue Ridge HP metabasites are similar to P‐T paths determined previously from Caledonian and Variscan eclogites. Thermobarometric similarities imply a common tectonic history of continental collision, subduction of continental crust to depths of 50–65 km, followed by rapid eduction.