Old Wine in New Bottles: A Feminist Perspective on Gilligan's Theory

Osnove etike in moralne refleksije

“…S trditvijo, da so »moški racionalnejši«, »ženske pa skrbnejše«, lahko namreč zgolj utrjujemo spolne stereotipe, zaradi česar za nekatere feministke ta teorija ni nič drugega kot staro vino v novih steklenicah (prim. Gould (1988)).…”

Measuring Nurses' Moral Judgments

“…Hardy (1978) suggested borrowing theories from other disciplines is appropriate when they are empirically validated to determine their congruence with nursing knowledge and practice. As with Kohlberg's theory, Gilligan's framework has many critics (Gould, 1988;Greeno &Moccoby, 1986;Luria, 1986;Walker, 1984Walker, , 1986. Adoption of Gilligan's theory is premature however, according to Huggins and Scalzi (1988), there is sufficient empirical support to question the exclusive use of Kohlbergian measures of moral reasoning in nursing research.…”