Occupational Physicians’ Reasoning about Recommending Early Return to Work with Work Modifications

Abstract

Previous research indicates that work modifications can effectively enhance return to work (RTW) at an early stage of work disability. We aimed to examine how occupational physicians (OPs) reason about recommending early return to work (RTW) with work modifications. Pre-defined propositions regarding the use of work modifications in promoting early RTW were discussed in four focus groups with altogether 11 Finnish OPs. Discussions were audio recorded, and the transcribed data were analyzed using qualitative content analysis. Five different rationales for supporting early RTW were identified: to manage medical conditions, to enhance employee well-being, to help workplace stakeholders, to reduce costs to society, and to enhance OP’s own professional fulfillment. However, OPs identified situations and conditions in which early RTW may not be suitable. In addition, there were differences between the OPs in the interpretation of the rationales, suggesting variation in clinical practice. In conclusion, encouraging early RTW with work modifications was perceived by OPs as a meaningful task and, to a large extent, beneficial for employees and several stakeholders. However, this practice was not accepted without consideration to the RTW situation and context. If early RTW and work modifications are to be promoted, OPs should be offered education that addresses their views regarding this practice.

Comparative study on the activities of part-time occupational physicians in Japan between 2008 and 2016: effects of the stress-check program

“…A third limitation of the present study is that, while both musculoskeletal disorder and mental ill health were some of main symptoms reported by employees in Europe 41) , musculoskeletal disorder issues were not specifically addressed in the present analyses. In addition, Horppu et al 42) stressed the positive role of OPs in enabling the early return of employees to workplaces after episodes of musculoskeletal pain or depressive symptoms.…”

Working Together and Being Physically Active Are Not Enough to Advise Uniformly and Adequately Low Back Pain Patients: A Cross-Sectional Study

“…Concerning recommendations, the relevant differences with the physicians were for the severity of pathology, and the recommendations for work, physiotherapists were more restrictive than physicians. This may be because the physicians are especially trained to diagnose pathologies and to certificate medical leave [ 59 ]. Conversely, the physiotherapists' training on LBP and chronic pain is often more focused on biomedical approach (e.g., manual therapy) than on exercise therapy and on the biopsychosocial approach although the biopsychosocial approach is also part of their training and profession.…”

Application of the Theoretical Domains Framework and the Behaviour Change Wheel to Understand Physicians’ Behaviors and Behavior Change in Using Temporary Work Modifications for Return to Work: A Qualitative Study

“…Knowledge developed in the pilot interviews led to foci for discussion in subsequent focus groups [ 6 ]:…”

“…Work accommodations can include modified or alternate duties, workstation redesign, activity restrictions, reduced hours, or other efforts to temporarily reduce physical or mental work demands. In our earlier qualitative study, occupational physicians considered SAW/RTW with temporary work modifications (TWMs) to a large extent beneficial for employees and other stakeholders if the RTW situation and context are taken into consideration [ 6 ].…”