Observed Circumvention of the Gutka Smokeless Tobacco Ban in Mumbai, India

Abstract

Objectives: Gutka is industrially manufactured in India and some Indian states have instituted bans on the sale of manufactured gutka as a public health initiative. We explored whether gutka was still available for purchase after the ban and also sought to observe methods of ban circumvention. Methods: We visited 5 different markets at different locations separated by at least 15-20 km around the Mumbai Metropolitan Region (MMR) area, consisting of Mumbai and its satellite towns in Maharashtra, India during August- September, 2019. In each location, purveyors were queried as to the availability of gutka. Results: Tobacco purchases were made in 5 locations/sections of MMR. At all markets, banned gutka was not displayed, and could only be purchased after requesting from the shopkeeper. Three methods of ban circumvention were observed: (1) packages marked 'export only'; (2) use of twin packaging in which pan masala and tobacco are sold together for immediate mixing to create gutka; and, (3) non-descript packaging without mention of 'gutka'. Conclusions: Although not readily displayed in shops, gutka is readily available in MMR, despite a statewide ban in Maharashtra. Marketers have used multiple methods to circumvent the statewide gutka ban.

Tobacco market trends in 97 countries between 2007 and 2021

“…However, previous research has reported no change in the prevalence of chewing tobacco use in India between 1990 and 2019 8 . This contrasts with our findings, possibly because the Euromonitor data did not capture illegal sales of smokeless tobacco, which has been reported in India before 23 . This emphasizes the importance of considering sales and prevalence data together to obtain a more comprehensive understanding of tobacco use.…”

How does Indian news media report smokeless tobacco control? A content analysis of the gutka ban enforcement

“…Rewards in the form of cash (n = 2) were also a motivating factor, which relate to two studies arguing that the effect of enforcement is stronger when officials are compensated by the fines collected [43,44]. Several barriers raised by the news are consistent with global and Indian tobacco control literature, particularly with regard to gutka, where legal loopholes, lack of awareness and enforcement, and litigation by tobacco industries are associated with violation of the ban, sale of twin packets, without mandated health warnings [31,45,46]. Only four reports mentioned the role of academia or NGOs, in…”

Exploring barriers of quitting smokeless tobacco among coronary artery disease patients of India: A qualitative study

“…33,34 Many Indian states have banned the sale and advertising of Gutka (a common form of SLT) but a recent study asserts that it is readily available in Indian markets. 35 Carrying a fatalistic attitude towards health was identified as another major driving force for continuing SLT among our CAD patients. Previous studies have identified belief in fate as a hindrance to behavioural change.…”

“…33,34 Many Indian states have banned the sale and advertising of Gutka (a common form of SLT) but a recent study asserts that it is readily available in Indian markets. 35…”