There have been several reports of phase-dependent noise in time-domain reflectivity studies of optical phonons excited by femtosecond laser pulses in semiconductors, semimetals, and superconductors. It was suggested that such behavior is associated with the creation of squeezed phonon states although there is no theoretical model that directly supports such a proposal. We have experimentally re-examined the studies of phonons in bismuth and gallium arsenide, and find no evidence of any phase-dependent noise signature associated with the phonons. We place an upper limit on any such noise at least 40-50 dB lower than previously reported. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevB.81.224304 PACS number͑s͒: 78.47.jg, 63.20.Ϫe, 42.50.Lc Coherent phonons in semiconductors, superconductors, metals, and insulators have been widely studied in the time domain since the first report of their excitation by femtosecond laser pulses in about 1990.1,2 The most general excitation mechanism is impulsive stimulated Raman scattering ͑ISRS͒.3 A special case of ISRS in opaque materials is sometimes referred to as the displacive mechanism 1 and is associated with electronic excitation from bonding to antibonding orbitals. Longitudinal optical phonons in semiconductors can also be driven by the transient polarization associated with the screening of surface space-charge fields following interband excitation.
2The amplitude of a phonon mode may be decomposed into two quadrature components with the time dependences cos t and sin t. In a coherent state, the closest quantum counterpart to a classical field, the fluctuations in the two quadratures have the same variance and are randomly distributed in phase. The product of the variances in each quadrature is the minimum allowed by the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. Minimum uncertainty states in which the fluctuations in one quadrature have a variance that falls below the zero-point quantum noise level are called squeezed states. 4 Squeezed electromagnetic fields were experimentally studied for the first time in the mid-1980s ͑Ref. 5͒ and nonclassical light is now an established area of research.6 A phasedependent nonlinear process is necessary to generate a squeezed state. For example, squeezed optical fields can be produced by parametric amplification or four-wave mixing. Recently, there has been interest in extending the study of nonclassical fields to lattice vibrations in condensed matter but except for a few studies of squeezing, 7-12 and amplitude collapse and revival, 13 there has been relatively little work on phonon fields. Squeezing of phonons generated by secondorder Raman scattering was predicted 7 and later reported 9,11 in low temperature, femtosecond pump-probe transmission measurements on KTaO 3 . In this case the mechanism is a three-phonon parametric process analogous to that used to produce coherent two-photon states. This type of experiment has been extended to the creation of coexcited coherent and squeezed vibrations 10 and to squeezed spin waves 14 in MnF 2 but in no case has the...