Research into teachers' conceptions of teaching can be justified in that deep seated beliefs impact upon the way teachers teach and influence the learning approaches of their students. This study examined conceptions of teaching art, through interviews with 18 secondary school art teachers in Hong Kong. The analysis resulted in a two-level characterisation of conceptions under broad essentialist and contextualist orientations. There were four subordinate conception categories, namely moral development in art and aesthetic development in art under the essentialist orientation, and intellectual development through art, and expression and therapy through art as sub-categories of the contextualist orientation. The categories were defined and delimited by six dimensions. The categories were seen as clearly distinguishable but related, though not hierarchically. There was no evidence of the category scheme being culturally specific, as the majority of the teachers held beliefs which were not consistent with the traditional manner of Chinese painting.
Abstract JADE 23.3 ©NSEAD 2004
Conceptions of teaching artThere has been a considerable amount of research into teachers' beliefs or conceptions of teaching [1][2][3][4][5]. Part of the justification is that the conceptions have a strong influence on how teachers teach. The topic has been of particular interest when reform has been on the agenda as deep seated beliefs can be hard to change, and so can be an important factor in determining whether reforms are successfully implemented. Teachers can be successful change agents but can also be obstacles for change when the proposed reform challenges their conceptions of teaching [6][7][8][9].In higher education conceptions of teaching have been found to be largely independent of discipline. A review of thirteen studies [10], each of which encompassed a range of disciplines, found that category schemes could be synthesised into a common model with two broad over-arching orientations towards either teachercentred / content-oriented or student-centred / learning-oriented conceptions. The teacher-and student-centred distinctions have also been commonly found in school teachers' conceptions.There have been few empirical studies of conceptions of teaching art. Chapman [11] researched 27 prospective teachers who were majoring in art education and confirmed four hypothesised conceptions, namely, the personalist, idealist, experimentalist and realist. The result can be explained by the teacher-or studentcentred terminology with the former two characterised as student-oriented conceptions and the remainder more teacher-directed. Apple [12] conducted a large sample survey of general teachers' attitudes towards art. There were positive indications of attitudes in three areas of significance, i.e. individual, societal, and instructional. The results suggest that teachers may carry more than one belief in teaching, as suggested by Pajaras [13].As there are multiple contrasting potential frameworks, derived from theory, for teachers' beliefs...