O096 Does boron bioactive glass have a role in bone regeneration?

Abstract

Introduction Bioactive glasses (BGs) provide an alternative to allogenic bone grafts. Various ions can be incorporated into the BGs structure to further influence regenerative or antimicrobial properties. Boron has recently been purposed as element that can be incorporated into BGs to promote desirable cellular regenerative response. This study aims to systematically review literature to determine the level of evidence that boron bioactive glasses (BBGs) and boron can promote desirable bone regenerative responses both in vitro and in vivo. Methods A systematic review of Web of Science was conducted in accordance with PRISMA guidelines. Data collected included bone cell behavioural analysis in response to boron or BBG compared to controls. Material properties of BBG (mechanical properties, degradation rate) compared to BG were compared. Results A total of 105 articles were included; 98 regarding BBG, and 12 articles studying the effect of boron. A higher biodegradation rate was observed in BBG compared with silicate-based BGs. BBGs have a lower compressive strength and increased fragility, as the percentage of B203 increases. 16 articles demonstrated a positive correlation with BBG and expression of OCN, VEGF, osteopontin, and RUNX2. Overall, metabolic activity of cells up to 14 days was lower in comparison to media and silicate BG. Conclusion BBGs have gained increased attention in the literature but the lack of heterogeneity and paucity of data does not provide convincing evidence of the effect of boron on bone regeneration and indicates the need for further quantitative research with a standardised approach to assessment. Take-home message Bioactive glasses can promote regeneration of bone, however the lack of heterogeneity and paucity of data regarding boron bioactive glass indicate the need for further quantitative research and standardised approach to assessment.