Nutritional quality and greenhouse gas emissions of vegetarian and non-vegetarian primary school meals: A case study in Dijon, France

Abstract

Since 2018 in France, national regulation mandates that school canteens serve a weekly vegetarian meal to reduce school canteens' environmental impact in addition to previous regulations imposing nutritional composition guidelines. However, a lunch without meat is often perceived as inadequate to cover the nutritional needs of children. The present study aims to assess the nutritional quality and greenhouse gas emissions (GHGE) of vegetarian and non-vegetarian school meals served in primary schools in Dijon, France. The catering department provided the composition of 249 meals served in 2019. Nutritional content and GHGE were retrieved from national food databases. The portion size of each meal component was the standard portion size recommended by the relevant French authority (GEMRCN). Meals were classified into vegetarian meals, i.e., without meat or fish (n = 66), or non-vegetarian meals (n = 183). The nutritional adequacy of the meals for children aged from 6 to 11 years was estimated using the mean adequacy ratio (MAR/2,000 kcal) as the mean percentage of daily recommended intake for 23 nutrients and the mean excess ratio (MER/2,000 kcal) as the mean percentage of excess compared to the maximum daily recommended value for three nutrients. This analysis of actual school meals shows that both vegetarian and non-vegetarian meals had a similar good nutritional quality with MAR/2,000 kcal of 87.5% (SD 5.8) for vegetarian and of 88.5% (SD 4.5) for non-vegetarian meals, and a MER/2,000 kcal of 19.3% (SD 15.0) for vegetarian and of 19.1% (SD 18.6) for non-vegetarian meals. GHGE were more than twofold reduced in vegetarian compared to non-vegetarian meals (0.9 (SD 0.3) vs. 2.1 (SD 1.0) kgC02 eq/meal). Thus, increasing the frequency of vegetarian meals, by serving egg-based, dairy-based or vegan recipes more frequently, would reduce GHGE while maintaining adequate nutritional quality of primary school meals.

Students’ Environmental Care Attitude: A Study at Adiwiyata Public High School Based on the New Ecological Paradigm (NEP)

“…Students can become more environmentally aware through interaction with the environment [93]. According to research conducted in France, greenhouses can enhance students' environmental awareness [94]. This differs from research conducted in England, which indicates that the use of greenhouses can reduce gas emissions and stabilize school climate [95].…”

Healthy and sustainable school meals – proposal for a new quality index SMI-LE

“…Analysis of school meals in France showed that both vegetarian and non-vegetarian meals had a similar good nutritional quality, but greenhouse gas emissions were more than twofold reduced in vegetarian compared to nonvegetarian meals. The authors concluded that increasing the frequency of vegetarian meals, by serving egg-based, dairy-based or vegan recipes more frequently, would reduce greenhouse gas emissions while maintaining adequate nutritional quality of primary school meals [19]. Besides, a study of 5,000 lunches served in the USA during the 2014-15 school year, indicated that redesigning school lunches could provide high-quality nutrition while benefiting the environment, and additionally reducing food costs, as the estimated food costs were lower for school lunches meeting sustainability (EAT-Lancet) targets than for traditional school lunches [37].…”

“…Since 2018 in France, national regulation encourages school canteens to serve a vegetarian meal weekly, to increase the proportion of organic products up to 20%, to limit the use of plastic, and to prevent food waste in order to reduce the environmental impact of school canteens. Moreover, a daily vegetarian option at primary school canteens was proposed in 2021 [19]. In Sweden, many schools and municipalities attempt to reduce the environmental footprint, e.g., by serving more vegetarian meals or organic foods, or even calculating associated emissions of greenhouse gases.…”

Schulen im (Klima-)Wandel – Handlungsfelder

“…Die Verteilung und das Kochen spielen eine untergeordnete Rolle. Durch einen höheren Anteil von Obst und Gemüse und eine gesündere Zubereitung mit weniger Zucker, Salz und Fett können der ökologische Fußabdruck zusätzlich minimiert und der Nährwert gesteigert werden 27 , 28 .…”