Nursing and euthanasia: A narrative review of the nursing ethics literature

Abstract

Background: Medical Assistance in Dying, also known as euthanasia or assisted suicide, is expanding internationally. Canada is the first country to permit Nurse Practitioners to provide euthanasia. These developments highlight the need for nurses to reflect upon the moral and ethical issues that euthanasia presents for nursing practice. Purpose: The purpose of this article is to provide a narrative review of the ethical arguments surrounding euthanasia in relationship to nursing practice. Methods: Systematic search and narrative review. Nine electronic databases were searched using vocabulary developed from a stage 1 search of Medline and CINAHL. Articles that analysed a focused ethical question related to euthanasia in the context of nursing practice were included. Articles were synthesized to provide an overview of the literature of nursing ethics and euthanasia. Ethical Considerations: This review was conducted as per established scientific guidelines. We have tried to be fair and respectful to the authors discussed. Findings: Forty-three articles were identified and arranged inductively into four themes: arguments from the nature of nursing; arguments from ethical principles, concepts and theories; arguments for moral consistency; and arguments from the nature of the social good. Key considerations included nursing’s moral ontology, the nurse–patient relationship, potential impact on the profession, ethical principles and theories, moral culpability for acts versus omissions, the role of intention and the nature of the society in which euthanasia would be enacted. In many cases, the same assumptions, values, principles and theories were used to argue both for and against euthanasia. Discussion: The review identified a relative paucity of literature in light of the expansion of euthanasia internationally. However, the literature provided a fulsome range of positions for nurses to consider as they reflect on their own participation in euthanasia. Many of the arguments reviewed were not nursing-specific, but rather are relevant across healthcare disciplines. Arguments explicitly grounded within the nature of nursing and nurse–patient relationships warrant further exploration.

Attitudes Study of Students and Staff of Nursing about Euthanasia in Behbahan City, 2018

“…A recent publication detailing nurses' involvement with euthanasia in the first 6 months of its implementation in the Canadian context offered similar findings [14]. In light of the moral and ethical complexity of this act, a number of authors have encouraged nurses to engage in discussions around euthanasia [15,16,17]. However, they are acquainted with the relevant challenges as they pass theoretical courses in professional ethics.…”

The rocks and hard places of MAiD: a qualitative study of nursing practice in the context of legislated assisted death

“…In consideration of the importance of the registered nursing role, and the new role for nurse practitioners in Canada, we conducted a study in which we explored the policy, practice, and ethical implications of MAiD for nursing. This was a two-phased study in which we first conducted systematic reviews of the literature [12][13][14] and then a qualitative study of Canadian nurses' experiences with MAiD. As part of the literature synthesis we gathered and analyzed nursing regulatory documents that were created to guide nursing practice in MAiD from the 10 provinces and 3 territories in Canada [13].…”

An overview of 5‐year patterns and trends in the Journal of Nursing Management

“…Advances in medicine, including detection, treatment, prevention together with improved socio‐economic circumstances, increased access to health care and improved understandings of the contribution of lifestyle mean not only that people are living longer, but older people are presenting with a novel co‐morbidity with consequential impacts on personal health, personal needs and the vision for societal support of the ageing population (Kagan, , ). There are also concurrent ethical issues as society struggles with treatment decisions, end of life care, and emerging policy and legislation related to euthanasia internationally (Pesut et al, ). In this Journal, Silén and Svantesso (:1) recently drew attention not only to the presence of ethical issues in health care, but the effect that these have on nurses’ well being.…”